News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by timthelion on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:23AM (#13036522)
When the Czech republic and other ex-soviet states dropped communism and started "moving west", the west greeted these countries with open arms and a chorus of "opening your countries up to foreign investments will spur growth and make your economies flower!" The Czech Republic responded, by allowing foreign investments essentially without reservations. This lead to a highly corrupt fire sale, called the "privatization process" in which state assets were sold off for far bellow market price to foriegn investors. Czech people, just comming out of communism, of course, could not afford to invest in their own country. Now, most of the valulable assets have been sold off, and the Czechs, to a large extent, live in a country which they do not own.

Now, when the Chineese do the same thing, but in much fairer circumstances (Germany is hardly recovering from a repressive communist regeim), we're crying foul? I do not like foreign investment, but a part of me is satisfied, that the West is finally getting a taste of it's own medicine. Not that it will reverse the damage done, and not that two wrongs make a right.

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by timthelion on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:40AM (#13036650)
At the same time, there is a similar smell of unfairness. Chineese companies a free to invest in the west, but western companies aren't free to invest in China. China is like "we're all for free trade, but no, Google can't buy Baidu" or whatever.
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by dforrestwilson1 on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:43AM (#13036668)
Firms in China also have massive state subsidies due to currency controls and bank funding requirements.

In the 1980s Japan went on an international buying spree only to see its economy crash in the late 80s/90s. Eventually even government supported economies crash, and when that happens Chinese companies may regret being so aggressively acquisitive.

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by jza00425 on Friday November 25, 2016 @01:29PM (#13038823)
If Google buy Baidu, I am sure there will be another Chinese company which will buy Google. Are u OK with that?
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by Create on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:31AM (#13036588)
This is one of the reasons why Europe is falling apart. The hidden cynical double standard always trumped good will. Brexit voters were unusually open (in a secret ballot) about east-west relationships.
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by Create on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:16AM (#13036838)
Dear downvoter:

The production and exports of cars, run by foreign owners, is a key driver of economic growth in the eastern European Union member where wages for skilled workers are well below Western European levels.

Daimler workers in Germany, where wages are much higher, took part in strikes earlier this year, which led to a deal in May to lift wages by 4.8 percent in the metal and electrical engineering sectors in Germany.

http://www.euronews.com/2016/11/24/hungarian-mercedes-worker...

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by timthelion on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:37AM (#13036971)
You mean "Daimler workers in Hungary" right?
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by wowoc on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:33AM (#13036600)
The same happened in Poland (and other countries from behind the Iron Curtain). Most stuff here has German or French owners now.
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by timthelion on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:58AM (#13036736)
Do you live in Poland? I live in Prague, and here, I'm surprised at how little people care about the foreign investment aspect of the privatization process. Even though almost everyone complains that it is corrupt, people here are mostly pro-west. The economy is strong here, and people don't see a big problem. Sure, we were among the richest countries in Europe pre WWII, but that was a long time ago, and people are now used to being relatively poor. But outside of Prague, especially on the Moravian side of the country I think opinions are very different, and many people actively say that "communism was better" and that the west has robbed the country. It is true, that heavy industry, like the car maker škoda auto (Now owned by VW), and the slevarny (metal making firms that are owned by the west), and the coal mines(owned by the Swiss) are all outside of Prague... Do Pols realise the extent that they were robbed?
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by timthelion on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:32AM (#13036936)
I just realised that my post comes across as pro-totalitarian communism. But that wasn't my point at all. My point wasn't that I think that things were "better during communism" my point was simply to try to present the opinions of those who do understand that the pro-western privitization process was unfair.

I just think that a more moderate, slower, and fairer privitization process would have been better for the citizens of the country, and not that we should have stayed totalitarian/communist.

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by hiacynt on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:28AM (#13036906)
More Poles realise this now, but they are often frowned upon by the mainstream media (surprise, surprise - they are mostly German-owned) and called regressive, nationalistic, etc. But the trends are rather positive, we now have a government that seems to support Polish industry, and peoples' attitudes have changed. For example, there's a very popular mobile app called Pola, which tells you how much a product is "Polish" (it computes a score based on where the owners are located, whether the company does R&D in Poland, and so on) based on barcodes. It's actually pretty trendy now, and it's not uncommon to see people scanning stuff with it in supermarkets. More about it here: https://growthengine.withgoogle.com/intl/en-eu/voices#card-s...

Interesting fact - some people responsible for the sell out to the west have been recently given prominent positions in Ukraine's government structures.

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by lossolo on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:30AM (#13036927)
@wowoc

Why you have created another account just to write that?

You wrote the same comment as wowoc and deleted it.

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by timthelion on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:36AM (#13036966)
Perhaps they don't want their normal screen name to be associated with pro-nationalistic views, as they are un-popular. I imagine that if I were a Pol working for a German software company, I would feel uncomfortable writing what OP just wrote under my normal screen name :P
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by wowoc on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:55AM (#13037092)
I don't have pro-nationalistic views, that's a purely economic issue to me - its result is a long-lasting drain of capital. I did feel somewhat weird after posting that though, and @lossolo caught me.
Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by tjelen on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:19AM (#13037725)
On the other hand, I remember that there were lot of Czech companies that were privatized into Czech hands and most of them do not exist anymore, because they went bankrupt a long time ago.

At the time (during the 90s), most of those companies that had foreign investors/management grew and survived and those that didn't were often tunneled-out by a corrupt management and were closed down. There were definitely some pretty big cases in 90s. Also there was a big public discussion about this at the time, and many politicians were against the foreign investments in general.

So I simply don't think that it's so clear-cut issue and that it's not like most of Czech people are completely unaware of the problem.

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by timthelion on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:24PM (#13038271)
You are, of course right, that the privatization process wouldn't have ended up being magically perfect if foreign investment would have been banned. There is so much awfulness that happened around the privitization process... And I wonder, if škoda hadn't been bought, would it have simply gone bankrupt after having been tunneled.

But if škoda had gone bankrupt, then that wouldn't have been an end to the Kolín, Mladé Boleslav, Leipzig industrial triangle. Cars would still be made here, given the huge amount of equipment and expertise in the area. But with škoda owned by VW, it cements a market dominance which is hard to shake. In a way, capital ownership is perminant.

A worse case is that of the swiss owned coal mines in the north. We behave as though those are still state owned mines. We kick people out of their houses with the power of the law. But the profits flow across the border to the west. Personally, I think that the government should pass a law that would re-nationalize the mines, without paying anything for them. The Chinese would certainly re-nationalize their mines if they were in the same situation. Right now, we behave as if capitalism is absolute, and democracy is relative to capitalism. The people cannot vote to confiscate the mines, but the companies can certainly bribe elected officials into privatizing them. So privatization is a one way process which puts more power into the hands of capitalists and takes power from the voters.

And now the Chinese are buying assets in democratic countries, and we are sitting here with our hands folded, saying "well, capitalism must come first. Democracy must never be allowed to interfere with the needs of capitalism." Which will be the death of democracy, unless we learn to dissobey capitalism and vote for things that break the rules of absolute and perminant ownership.

Re:Germany’s Chinese investment problem by msolujic on Saturday November 26, 2016 @12:39AM (#13041906)
Same privarization scheme was applied to all statea in eastern Europe post iron curtain fall. Serbia is one example of huge corruption during privatization of companies