News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brew commands send data to Google Analytics by TeMPOraL on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:10AM (#13035288)
Yes, there are arguments for organ donation to be opt-out. But that's extreme case, when one loses literally nothing - by virtue of being already dead - and another person stands to gain additional years of life[0]. Some other socially beneficial things also have strong arguments for being opt-out (like retirement plans, because opt-out protects people from their own stupidity/short-sightedness).

But that doesn't change the validity of the proposal that opt-in should be the standard - exceptions from which must have solid reasons. Just making it easier for someone to make money off people is not one of those reasons. Neither is vague "making the product better".

--

[0] - INB4 yes, there are also valid arguments that opt-out organ donations will reduce doctors' willingness to fight for patient's life. Human societies are complicated.

Re:Brew commands send data to Google Analytics by tremon on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:19AM (#13035336)
Yes, there are arguments for organ donation to be opt-out. But that's extreme case, when one loses literally nothing

Actually, I've opted out because my next of kin stand to lose quite a lot (the harvesting of organs needs to be done quickly, well within the mourning period of the people I care about the most). The decision to leave sight of my body needs to be theirs, and theirs alone.

Re:Brew commands send data to Google Analytics by orf on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:40AM (#13035439)
Well if you can't bear the thought of your friends and relatives not being able to stare at your dead corpse for a couple of hours and value that over doing something amazing and saving someone's life then more fool you.

If your in the position to donate organs you most likely died in an accident. You likely won't have that rosy picture of your family and friends around your beside. You might not have anyone.

What a waste.

Re:Brew commands send data to Google Analytics by tremon on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:04AM (#13035854)
Yes, fuck you too. Try a little empathy next time, and failing that, reading comprehension.

I said the decision should be theirs. I did not say my body couldn't be parted from them, I said it was their decision to do so. I used to be registered as a donor, but because the law has now changed that my donorship overrides the wishes of my loved ones, I have withdrawn it.

Re:Brew commands send data to Google Analytics by orf on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:30AM (#13035953)
> I said it was their decision to do so

And I said they may not be there to give that decision, so that's moot really. Organs like lungs and hearts expire very quickly. Reading comprehension indeed.

> Try a little empathy next time

For the dead person, or the person who misses out on a life saving organ due to the dead person?

It's your body and your choice obviously, but I think saying it's up to my relatives to decide isn't a great reason to be taken off the donor registry. There is plenty of time for them to grieve but only a few hours to take a vital organ. If you want to do something great if you expire unexpectedly then it's up to you, don't put that on your parter/relatives.