Either way I disagree. Both approaches have pros and cons depending on the type of analysis.
At the very least, just the presence of competing approaches in the field has pushed statisticians to have more rigour and do way more double checking than they might have, out of fear the other side actively looking to poke holes. It's easy to lie with statistics and the only people who can call statisticians out on their BS is other statisticians...Need more of this.
Nope.
> Both approaches have pros and cons
What are the pros of the frequentist approach?
Now. You might read this as me saying that Bayesian statistics is all made up, and that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying that if you go Bayesian all the way, and your result is even remotely controversial, someone could easily challenge you by saying "this result would have been different with different priors, and why won't they just come out and say p < 0.01? What are they hiding?"
When you do frequentist statistics, the equivalent of priors were, instead, made up for you by long scientific tradition. They're not very good priors, as the relevant xkcd illustrates. But at least it's not you making them up.
In a more complex model, there's also the thing where you can't calculate the result exactly, you have to approximate it with Markov Chain Monte Carlo or something, leading to another way to doubt your results (did the MCMC converge correctly?)
So instead you do frequentist statistics. You use your favorite stats package and it spits out a nice comforting p-value that will satisfy the reviewers. You have tons of guidance about how to do things. It's not a great thing, but it is a definite advantage of using frequentist statistics.
How about this: find me a published scientific paper with only Bayesian results in it, no frequentist statistics at all. Argue for its superiority all you want, but I don't think anyone does it. It would be seen as a stunt.
https://www.amazon.com/Proving-History-Bayess-Theorem-Histor...
Trivial¹, surely?
> [B]ut I don't think anyone does it. It would be seen as a stunt.
What did you mean by "scientific"?
You'd have to hunt for a narrow reading s.t. the above holds — extant counterexamples aren't limited to any one branch.
Check it out² for yourself.
Further: cogsci's bayesian adoption is rapidly accelerating.
The replication crisis is brutalizing huge swathes of psych:
• loss of confidence in NHST is becoming near-total for many
• journals are purging in turn — e.g. BASP's p-value ban³⁴
• others are overhauling stats-in-psych entirely
J Math Psych alone has two recent special issues⁵⁶ on this.
I mean:
> no frequentist stats at all
isn't even a strawman lately, let alone an absurdity.
In some fields, it's a battle-cry.
All that being said… re:
> Argue for its superiority all you want
I wouldn't even go that far. Don't give em that.
Probability interpretation fundies
• are all wrong,
• narrow minds and waste lifespans with the cultism, and
• should at least learn of the other interpretations.
Pitching probability as a 1v1 isn't merely wrong-prime⁷ — it's doublepluswrong″⁸.
It's pseudofundamentalism: fundies uphold foundations.
Flamewars predicated on ignorance of the same gotta go, no matter how fashionable they may be.
____________________________________________________________
[1] http://enwp.org/bayesian_game
[2] http://google.com/scholar?q=fully+bayesian
[3] http://doi.org/4z8 | BASP 37
[4] http://doi.org/34p | Nature re: BASP
[5] http://doi.org/btqx | J Math Psych 72
[6] http://doi.org/btqz | J Math Psych 74
Here is a simple example: lets say you flip a coin 10 times and get 8 heads, what is the probability that the coin is not fair? In frequentist statistics you only have to calculate the likelihood of the results for a null hypothesis, and then you use a p-value. While this approach is flawed, at least you can quickly do the calculation and get an approximate answer. In Bayesian statistics you have to specify the prior distribution, and calculate the likelihood of your results under every possible hypothesis. Correctly specifying this prior distribution and calculating the results is quite challenging - especially if you want to use a realistic prior (not just uniform). This is a pretty simple example, you can imagine how much more challenging this becomes in real-world problems. On the other hand, it is true that the frequentist approach doesn't really answer the question asked, so it is misleading (especially if you choose a p-value that isn't specific to the problem). If you choose p-values based on prior knowledge, than the differences between frequentist and bayesian are less extreme.
This is often a feature, forcing you to actually look at the complexity head on before you sweep it under a rug.
There are both Bayesian and Frequentist approaches in statistics!
They represent very different methods to statistics, but they are also quite similar. My apologies, I couldn't find one link that gave a good description of Bayesian vs. Frequentist. Here are a couple links to get started:
https://xkcd.com/1132/
http://jakevdp.github.io/blog/2014/03/11/frequentism-and-bay...
If anyone comes across a link that describes Bayesian and Frequentist clearly, please share it if you don't mind.