I can't see that holding up once challenged, especially if they find evidence of a crime by someone else on that computer for an unrelated matter.
Source: http://volokh.com/2010/04/27/thoughts-on-the-legality-of-the...
This part is my own interpretation, but I think it's reasonable: given the lack of direct precedent, the CA court that considers this matter will probably consider the legislative intent behind the law (Gizmodo is out of luck) and look to how similar laws have been interpreted (again, Gizmodo is out of luck).
"Initially it's just a theft investigation," Wagstaffe said. "But ultimately could it lead to more? That's going to depend on what they learn. That's why they would like to be able to look at the computer and interview everybody that they can so they can determine the extent of what's involved."
But see if it's a theft investigation and they thought what Gizmodo did was theft than they had enough to charge Chen for that. He'd confessed in public. They didn't need to raid the house to bring charges against him.
Being they haven't brought charges against him it looks like they were fishing for something that could "lead to more" and that's unacceptable.
IANAL but this seems like a big "well, duh" concept to me. What if Chen had knifed the iPhone thief in an alley, rather than paying him $5,000? Would the shield laws be relevant then?
The EFF and many other commentators seem to be very confused. This is not a potential "freedom of the press" case, it's a potential "receiving stolen property" case.
Yes, the way the law is written (which is how it usually has to be interpreted). They're not to protect Chen. The people whom he's talked to STILL need protection if he happens to be a suspect in a stabbing.
If the legislature of California wants to FIX the law, then by all means do so. But the law as written doesn't have that feature.
Exceptions USUALLY are only granted to make criminal based laws more lenient, not usually less.
However Chen is working as a journalist in CA, it looks like they have no right to get a warrant for those computers, they have to just subpoena the specific information and make Chen produce it that way. The CA shield law doesn't have an explicit exception to allow warrants in case of possible criminal acts by newspeople.