Re:Goldman Sachs Drops Out of R3 Blockchain Group
by jaekwon on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @09:04PM
(#13019369)
Whats the benefit of HB over Tendermint? There's a good reason we don't use threshold signatures... to guarantee accountability. We could add threshold signatures on top of Tendermint, but for most use cases this isn't very helpful (yet).
In any case, building on TMSP will make Texas future proof to any consensus engine that favors safety. Let's discuss.
Re:Goldman Sachs Drops Out of R3 Blockchain Group
by murbard2 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @12:22PM
(#13024066)
Yes, getting accountability needs to be addressed, we're looking at several ways. Makes no sense to build on TMSP, governance that introspects over the consensus mechanism is a key feature. We aspire to be a utility, not a vassal.
Overall I agree with Tendermint (and contra Casper or DFinity) that it's better to just drop availability and to have a less subjective security model. It sucks to get stuck if the validator set becomes compromised, but it's not the end of the world.