Re:It’s not the methods that are Agile, it’s the people
by TeMPOraL on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @01:41PM
(#13016345)
I'd add two more problems:
5. Football is a zero-sum PvP game, programming is a PvE race-the-clock game. In football, you don't have to be good, you just have to be not worse than other team (+/- luck factor). In programming, you have random obstacles (requirements, management decisions) thrown at you, the effort it takes to scale those obstacles is mostly unpredictable, and you're being pushed to do it before deadline "or else".
6. Timescale. American football match takes an hour (1.5 hour for soccer, + break). That's how much time the team works together until the next deliverable. In programming, it's weeks or months. Sustaining teamwork on such a long scale is a completely different task. If you want to compare something to football, look at hackatons - and then you'll see people who worked together before often excel at getting things done.
5. Football is a zero-sum PvP game, programming is a PvE race-the-clock game. In football, you don't have to be good, you just have to be not worse than other team (+/- luck factor). In programming, you have random obstacles (requirements, management decisions) thrown at you, the effort it takes to scale those obstacles is mostly unpredictable, and you're being pushed to do it before deadline "or else".
6. Timescale. American football match takes an hour (1.5 hour for soccer, + break). That's how much time the team works together until the next deliverable. In programming, it's weeks or months. Sustaining teamwork on such a long scale is a completely different task. If you want to compare something to football, look at hackatons - and then you'll see people who worked together before often excel at getting things done.