News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by omginternets on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:22AM (#13015123)
I'm reminded of this: https://youtu.be/pAEAbqrE5Zw

Does it represent a lot of work by skilled technicians? Undoubtedly. Is it interesting in it's own right? Frankly I think not.

The surrounding question of the socialization of the internet is interesting, to be sure, but at the end of the day these are just animated emojis...

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by seanwilson on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:58AM (#13015428)
> Does it represent a lot of work by skilled technicians? Undoubtedly. Is it interesting in it's own right? Frankly I think not.

You don't think having an easy way to create high quality animations for any purpose that work on multiple platforms is interesting...? You might not find the current application of it interesting but that's like saying React isn't interesting because someone used it to make another Flappy Bird game.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by omginternets on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @01:35PM (#13016287)
This is a fair point. I'm more so reacting to the tone of the article, which suggests technological or social innovation.

I see neither.

Analogously: TCP is pretty amazing, but I don't expect an app that uses a simple TCP socket to self-aggrandize on the pretext of technological innovation.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by kuschku on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @01:14PM (#13016097)
> You don't think having an easy way to create high quality animations for any purpose that work on multiple platforms is interesting...?

It would be more if they'd have created an extension to the SVG standard that they'd just parse out via JS. Then it'd just be a polyfill, and could easily be integrated natively in the future, and gain support on other platforms, too.

This will change the world for a few months, modifying the standard would change it for years.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by TheFarmingBunny on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @12:12PM (#13015549)
But react isn't interesting because they could have just modified custom elements via a polyfill and javascript extension. It would work mostly natively on newer browsers. Keyframes is just after effects animation in HTML5, a feature that could be implemented more natively using svg and a solution similar to this for older browsers. Facebook seems to want to dominate with single-use, clunky libaries.
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by xenadu02 on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @01:32PM (#13016256)
Yeah and on mobile devices you can waste a lot more battery running animations in HTML5. I'm sure your users will appreciate that. Surely the most important thing is to optimize programmer time and comfort without regard to the end-user experience and that thinking has lead to a world filled with wonderful well-designed software that properly handles error conditions and never presents users with useless choices or non-actionable obscure error messages.*

Snark aside, if you have a native mobile app it is a much, much nicer experience to have native animations integrated rather than trying to mash an HTML view into the app just for some animations.

*Because programmers are the worst kind of pedants: Yes I know sometimes you can't afford to write native apps, sometimes a partial solution is better than no solution, etc. Just don't lie and tell me a web app is as good as (or better than) a native app, or that Cordova is a great way to write mobile apps. Those are compromises. Sometimes you make compromises to get shit done. It doesn't magically transform a compromise into an ideal solution.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by seanwilson on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @12:15PM (#13015567)
> Keyframes is just after effects animation in HTML5, a feature that could be implemented more natively using svg and a solution similar to this for older browsers

That's another approach which has it's own pros and cons. The approach from the article is obviously good if you have Affect Effects experts on hand. I'm not understanding why this isn't interesting to programmers who on a daily basis have to weigh up the pros and cons of different technology/library choices.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by misio on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @12:57PM (#13015933)
>I'm not understanding why this isn't interesting to programmers who on a daily basis have to weigh up the pros and cons of different technology/library choices.

Perhaps I'm showing my age, but this feels like this problem was solved a long time ago, forgotten or unused to a large extent and now re-invented. Flash was the clever web version back in the day but I can't see anything really new in this.

I could absolutely be missing the point though. I never count that out.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by seanwilson on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @01:05PM (#13016001)
Flash isn't supported on mobile browsers (now), native Android or native iOS though.
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by misio on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @02:05PM (#13016562)
Oh, absolutely. It was a heavy implementation of a similar solution and the mobile ecosystem is better off without it.
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by tdb7893 on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:47AM (#13015324)
It might not be novel but it looks to be useful and well supported, which is really what counts in JS libraries
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by nkozyra on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:59AM (#13015445)
It's been a while since I've seen that episode, but ... wasn't that _the_ product in SV? This represents a small bit of UX that may be compelling enough to keep users engaged in new ways on their primary product (a relatively large social media site, ftr).
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by omginternets on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @01:57PM (#13016476)
Yes. It's an analogy.

The purpose of an analog is not to be exactly identical, otherwise it would be called an equality.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by nkozyra on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @10:49PM (#13019817)
I'm sorry, it doesn't seem remotely comparable. Huge, complicated products are often made of seemingly inconsequential pieces. That SV piece was about an entire product made of an inconsequential piece of tech.
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by jsprogrammer on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:24AM (#13015139)
It was interesting enough for FB to strip down and repackage https://github.com/bodymovin/bodymovin
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by omginternets on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:29AM (#13015178)
Your example speaks to my point: there's nothing new, innovative, technically challenging (beyond the norm).

I really don't see what there is to write home about. This article reads as a PR announcement (which is okay) disguised as a technical achievement (which it isn't).

They're "just" animations.

Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by city41 on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:56AM (#13015402)
Maybe not the biggest breakthrough ever, but it does fill a gap. Animations like this on the web really weren't possible without either using Flash or SMIL. A completely JavaScript based solution is very welcome.
Re:Keyframes: Delivering scalable, high-quality animations t... by misio on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @02:08PM (#13016591)
I think the annoyance is the slightly smug tone of "Look what I invented. Vector animation and keyframes!"

It's a cool implementation but it feels like they are claiming to have broken amazing new ground. To people that don't understand much of the background technology that's exactly how it reads.