Secessionist movements typically underestimate the costs of separation. Like the UK post-Brexit, no one knows how an independent CA would relate to the rump US. Would it enjoy the free movement of goods, services and people? I doubt it.
There is almost no basis to consider Californians as a separate people, which is usually what drives self-determination. I live in CA. We do not share a common language or religion or history distinct from our neighbors.
Secessionists just show that they don't know how democracy works. Sometimes you lose, and sometimes you lose big.
I find this poem by Anna Akhmatova quite powerful and topical:
I am not one of those who left the land
to the mercy of its enemies.
Their flattery leaves me cold,
My songs are not for them to praise.
But I pity the exile's lot.
Like a felon, like a man half-dead,
dark is your path, wanderer;
wormwood infects your foreign bread.
But here, in the murk of conflagration,
where scarcely a friend is left to know,
we, the survivors, do not flinch
from anything, not from a single blow.
Surely the reckoning will be made
after the passing of this cloud.
We are the people without tears,
straighter than you...more proud...
(1922)
http://leopard.booklikes.com/post/874564/poems-of-anna-akhma...
The people who fly the traitor's flag would argue otherwise, but then, if they want to leave America, they are un-American, no?
Certainly that is another way to look at it. I can imagine that modern-day secessionists, like the CSA founders before them, would argue that it's the other guy who has changed.
How is it un-American when it's quite literally how America came about and why "American" is distinct from English.
I'ts about the most American thing I can think of.
I think something similar happened in Kosovo: secession of Kosovo from Serbia, secession of the four majority-Serbian counties of Kosovo from the rest of the province. (Or at least, I hope that second secession has gone through by now; I certainly remember there was a push towards it.)
It sounds like you'd say that permitting secession is wrong because it leads to ethnic cleansing. How much ethnic cleansing do you anticipate in the event of California seceding from the United States?
I'm saying secession leads to a lot of geopolitical instability and usually violence and loss, for very little gain.
I think multiple conflicts would arise if California tried to secede from the US. The first would be between the secessionists and federal forces. If the secessionists did not have the support of a foreign power, US federal forces would win, and even then...
The second conflict would be between the "leavers" and "remainers" within California, where the remainers would initiate their sub-secessions from the breakaway state of California. Here you can imagine the awful process of Partition in India, for example; or the Serbian minority in Bosnia.
And while everyone in CA is thinking they should be self-determining, we would see other political fractures. North v south. The coastal cities v the interior.
Russia Deploys New Missiles to the Baltic Sea Region http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2016/11/21/world/europe/ap-e...
We'll see a lot more erosion of our influence over the next few years while Trump's clown car rolls over US civil liberties. We have to focus. Secession is not the answer.
Finally, I'd simply point out to the "Yes California" people that large parts of California a) don't want to break away from the US (including but not limited to much of northern and eastern CA) and therefore b) would be perfectly within their rights to secede from the new nation state in an infinity of recursively splintering secessions that will finally be reduced to one dumb guy who cuts off his nose to grant it independence (and to spite his face).