Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by msandford on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:40PM
(#13010634)
Sometimes multiple wars are fought for roughly the same reason. The Scots have rebelled against England more than once, and they may still vote their way out due to brexit. Supposing that people are willing to accept defeat now due to historical reasons is empirically inadvisable.
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by krapp on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:44PM
(#13010670)
Any state willing to secede would no longer recognize the authority of the US government, or the Constitution, so that's a moot point. It was treason for the US to secede from Great Britain, but we did it anyway.
It's not a question of "can" or "can't," but whether or not a state is willing to fight another civil war.
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by AnimalMuppet on Monday November 21, 2016 @08:13PM
(#13010813)
It's not even whether the state is willing, but whether the people of the state are willing. I doubt whether California could field a sufficient force if the US government declared their succession illegal.
(Go out and get shot at rather than hitting the beach? C'mon...)
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by PretzelFisch on Monday November 21, 2016 @08:46PM
(#13010950)
That is what other foreign allies are for.
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by AnimalMuppet on Monday November 21, 2016 @09:12PM
(#13011072)
That are willing to fight the US military so that Californians can hit the beach rather than fight for their own independence? I doubt you'd find many takers.
And who would be the taker? Russia? China? North Korea? Iran? Venezuela? Are any of them going to really want to go against the US military within North America? (The closest I could see happening is some Russian statement of support and an attempt at nuclear blackmail, but few or no troops on the ground.)
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by koheripbal on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:56PM
(#13010740)
It's also a question of whether the borders of a state breaking away remain valid. While the cities of LA and SF might support secession, the rural residents occupying the remaining 98% of the actual territory in California would want to stay.
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by flukus on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:56PM
(#13010737)
Funny how the "land of the free" doesn't support self determination.
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by brightball on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:39PM
(#13010629)
I wasn't aware the legality of secession was ever officially ruled on. It was supposed to be part of the Jefferson Davis trial, but that never happened due to the full pardon of the entire south.
Re:Secessionists formally launch quest for California's inde...
by likpok on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:43PM
(#13010664)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_v._White
Arguably SCOTUS has ruled that you can't secede, and that the South did not in fact secede.
But read "Ecotopia" and "Ecotopia Emerging".