News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by pavs on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:38PM (#1300660)
Plentyoffish needs to hire a designer. Assuming the number he claims is true, how many users is he loosing because of the site layout?

I might sound like a snob, but I have a hard time taking a site designed like this seriously, I don't care how many users or traffic he claims to have.

As far as dating site designs go, OkCupid looks great.

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by petercooper on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @12:15AM (#1300731)
Plentyoffish needs to hire a designer. Assuming the number he claims is true, how many users is he loosing because of the site layout?

As many as Craigslist is "loosing," I suspect.

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by chime on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:44PM (#1300671)
> Plentyoffish needs to hire a designer.

I'd say he knows his target audience well enough to make that decision himself. There is indeed such a thing as being too polished. The reason late-night TV commercials are cheesy and loud is not because the director lacks the skills but rather because it suits the target market. If POF redesigned their site to look like a glamor magazine website, he might indeed lose a lot of users because they might be intimidated by the design.

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by pavs on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:55PM (#1300694)
Its doesn't even need to look like a glamor magazine website (none of the dating websites do). Even if he doesn't need to make the site look half decent, the design itself is broken. Thumbnails doesn't seem to be properly scaled, they seemed compressed in to a smaller version (I could be wrong but the thumbnails are screwed up for some reason) and what is this in ever profile? http://i.imgur.com/Knicz.png

Its less than 5 minutes worth of work to fix that.

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by shib71 on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @12:16AM (#1300733)
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by iamdave on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @08:30AM (#1301359)
I wonder where he got that old version of Risk, that still uses the figurines. This new version with the arrows completely sucks.
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by tortilla on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @12:11AM (#1300722)
I think I read that he actually mis-scales the images on purpose because of a higher click-thru rate.
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by dannyr on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @12:01AM (#1300702)
What matters to you may not matter to other people.

A lot of people have been saying that Craigslist should have better design, more search options, etc but the site is still popular.

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by cynicalkane on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @10:37AM (#1301622)
The difference is that Craigslist has good design already, whereas POF does not.
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by gte910h on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:42PM (#1300667)
Unfortunately for you, dating sites really suffer from power laws. A dating site with 2x people is 4x as effective
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by mistermann on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @12:13AM (#1300727)
I seem to recall reading an interview where this question was asked, and the answer was basically, don't mess with what works....the idea being that, if you're constantly improving, eventually you'll screw something up. He knows it's bad, but he doesn't want to screw things up.

But I agree with you, the design is painful to look at, and usability could be improved a lot. Why he doesn't clean things up a bit is beyond me.

But then, compared to the competitors, POF may not look so pretty, but functionally it is quite good.

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by hussong on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @02:12AM (#1300886)
Someone wrote that maybe the crappy, amateurish look gives the site more authenticity, much like a long-tail forum/bb.

If POF's UI was really slick, it might look too commercial for some people.

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by omd on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @03:00AM (#1300951)
It's true. I built the website for my brother's company 6 years ago and it looks, well, 6 years old. Even so his company gets 80% of new clients through the website. He always asks people why they chose him. Most say because they felt it looked like a professional company compared to the "flashy" companies that have more modern websites. I hate how it looks and he's embarrassed to refer people to it, but as long as it works we don't want to touch it.

Through the years we've watched the competition go through one design after another and try all kinds of SEO, but our crappy, framed, obtrusive javascript website still outranks them. The only downside is the constant calls we get from SEO and design firms offering to "help us out".

Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by hussong on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @04:42AM (#1301087)
Great example. Would you mind to share a link?
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by kyro on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:43PM (#1300670)
Most of the users that use that site don't care about ease of use. As long as they can find matches, for free, they're happy.
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by dc2k08 on Wednesday April 28, 2010 @01:13AM (#1300825)
I can offer one statistic that backs you up. A friend who had tried match.com without success asked me for dating site recommendations. I pointed her to PoF and OKCupid. She went with OKcupid over PoF saying the latter just looked cheap or 'seedy'. He could definitely improve the style sheet without going all super needlessly web 2.0. It would be interesting if he preformed some split tests with the design on new sign ups but perhaps he already has. I did read once that some e-book sellers purposely keep their sell pages looking less than beautiful as they realised it attracted more conversions. The reasoning they gave was that perhaps it gave the impression that they were just common ordinary people and therefor more likely to be trustworthy.
Re:Match.com no longer top dating site, sends in the lawyers by samratjp on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:53PM (#1300688)
You could say the same about myspace, but it's still alive.