News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by Spooky23 on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:29PM (#12997284)
I'm sure they've focus grouped this to death. Everyone wants battery life. It differentiates the product and sells computers.

Many people claim to need >16GB, but many of those folks really don't. The folks who need to run VMs (the biggest group, IMO) have workarounds.

The folks left are a small number and have alternatives, mostly in the cloud. And they make the Mac Pro to address those folks, although obviously that's a flawed product as well.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by dvtv75 on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:29AM (#12997588)
I know quite a few people who require >16GB, and not one of them is a power user nor do they use a VM. What they do is edit large amounts of 4K video in FCP, and they're rather screwed without an actual MacBook Pro.

No, there are no cloud options for them, they need the RAM for the video. No, the Mac Pro isn't a viable option for them at that price, nor is it portable.

I'm pretty sure they don't give a damn about battery life, either. They do their editing at a desk, and then take the MBP with them.

So, for now, they're stuck with old models until there's a better one, or they spend a fair amount of money building a new pipeline and purchasing new software.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by comex on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:04AM (#12997702)
What old models? As far as I know there aren't any older MacBooks that support more than 16GB of RAM either.

If you're going to compare to desktops, start with the iMac, which is "only" a year old at this point, unlike the Mac Pro which is several :(. The iMac with 5K display starts at $1,800 and is configurable to 32GB RAM, while the MacBook Pro 15" starts at $2,400, and then you probably want an external display too. (That doesn't include the rather high price of actually configuring the iMac for 32GB, but its RAM is [still] user-upgradeable, so better to buy it somewhere else.) Actually, considering that the Mac Pro starts at $3,000, which is not that much more than $2,400, I'm not sure why you think the price puts it out of range...

But I definitely understand why you'd want it in a laptop.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by FireBeyond on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:41AM (#12997928)
Well, the 32GB MBP price is "unknown", but the Mac Pro at 32GB is $3,500, not $3,000.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by cSoze on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:55AM (#12997680)
So their old MBPs have 32 GB? Have they just been unable to get anything done these past 40 years? The tech just isn't quite there yet. Next year.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by sumanthvepa on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:53AM (#12997669)
Even VMs can be run on these laptops. It takes effort to create them right. My clients routinely use machines with 4GB of RAM and need VMs to do development (We're in India). So we've made our VMs smaller and easier to install. The nice thing about that is when I demo to folks in Europe/US/Japan. Our stuff simply files on their hulking huge 16GB machines. Of course it's not free ride, one has to carefully eliminate packages on the guest VM that are not strictly necessary and carefully reduce the size of the image. Also they need to to avoid doing really large data computation on their VMs.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by thinkmassive on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:40AM (#12997783)
So your clients trade the cost of 4GB RAM (maybe a day or two worth of developer time) for having developers constantly tweak Linux images to run on a laptop with 4GB RAM? This is beyond simply removing packages, because you're talking about memory, not just disk space.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by sumanthvepa on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:22AM (#12997884)
Actually, we (or more accurately our software automation) tweaks the images. You're right about RAM. Part of what we do when we 'tweak' is move memory intensive processes to either the cloud or a datacenter. Our client's developers just install and use the VMs as they normally would. No tweaking on their part needed. So our clients are trading the time of their developers and cost of upgrading entire teams to fancy machines, to paying us to deal with the pain of tweaking images and dealing with the devops. Most of their developers are doing web development. But a lot of them want to replicate the entire stack for themselves on their local machines. So we enable some of that by simply having the automation create dedicated dbs etc for them on shared/cloud infra and create just we webdev environment in their local VM. For ourselves, Wwe use automation (and build it) and some nice hardware to do the development (Definitely not laptops for devops automation). But then we're only 3 people. So even though each of us has several workstations, servers and laptops at our disposal, our clients don't need such expense for each of their developers. Works out well for both parties. :-)
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by fooker on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:16AM (#12997870)
Eh, it shouldn't take much effort. Put Arch (or something similar), use openbox or LXDE for a reasonably useful GUI and you have an image that takes ..maybe.. 100 megs when idle.

You do not have to do this from scratch each time, just clone the disk, or even better have a script that generates these images modulo some parameters.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by thinkmassive on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:53AM (#12997965)
Server VMs shouldn't require a window manager. They also shouldn't be idle during testing though, and I would think 512 MB is a reasonable minimum for doing anything useful. Double that for a database.

My point is that you can get a laptop with 8GB RAM instead of 4GB and should pay for itself within a couple days.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by thinkmassive on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:55AM (#12997971)
...and yes, I'm aware this doesn't need to be done from scratch every time :)

It's still a waste of time if you need to reduce a standard minimal Linux install whatsoever (ISO via Packer, Vagrant, Docker, whatever the case may be)

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by Spooky23 on Sunday November 20, 2016 @09:09AM (#12998901)
Our engineering guys maintain images that are stripped and hardened for the dev team.

That way we don't waste time optimizing at deployment time or deploy crap into production.

Our java people need more memory and we addressed it by giving them server VMs and CI tools.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by ciconia on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:53AM (#12997813)
> I'm sure they've focus grouped this to death.

Apple? Focus-grouping?

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by jccalhoun on Sunday November 20, 2016 @09:37AM (#12999022)
I agree. there is no way they focus grouped this. I'm sure it was just Jony Ive saying "make it thinner. remove some buttons" and the engineering staff had to figure out how to do it.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by mtw on Sunday November 20, 2016 @11:13AM (#12999514)
How do you know many really don't 16GB? Does that comes from a study?