Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha...
by pdonis on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:15PM
(#12997234)
> to say that all of life is proven to have undergone both biological and chemical evolution because some microbes were seen evolving in a lab is a bit optimistic in my view.
You're ignoring a huge body of evidence: the fact that all living organisms on Earth use the same genetic material and the same genetic code. This is strong evidence for common descent, and common descent is an obvious prediction of the theory of evolution and requires highly implausible ad hoc hypotheses on any other assumption.
> how do entirely new species form if embryonic development is basically impossible?
It isn't impossible; it's just unlikely, because beneficial mutations are rare. But this is part of evolutionary theory.
> Many people have computed the approximate probabilities required to get a functioning protein from random mutations
These computations ignore the fact that natural selection is not random. That means the sequence of events from one functioning protein to another is not a random walk through the space of all possible proteins, as the computations assume.
(Computations based on permutations and combinations of atoms also ignore the fact that chemical reactions are not random; only a vanishingly small fraction of all possible mathematical combinations of atoms actually occur, the rest are chemically impossible.)
You're ignoring a huge body of evidence: the fact that all living organisms on Earth use the same genetic material and the same genetic code. This is strong evidence for common descent, and common descent is an obvious prediction of the theory of evolution and requires highly implausible ad hoc hypotheses on any other assumption.
> how do entirely new species form if embryonic development is basically impossible?
It isn't impossible; it's just unlikely, because beneficial mutations are rare. But this is part of evolutionary theory.
> Many people have computed the approximate probabilities required to get a functioning protein from random mutations
These computations ignore the fact that natural selection is not random. That means the sequence of events from one functioning protein to another is not a random walk through the space of all possible proteins, as the computations assume.
(Computations based on permutations and combinations of atoms also ignore the fact that chemical reactions are not random; only a vanishingly small fraction of all possible mathematical combinations of atoms actually occur, the rest are chemically impossible.)