Re:On vagueness, or, when is a heap of sand not a heap of sand?
by gumby on Saturday November 19, 2016 @08:51PM
(#12996839)
Alternatively you could consider a functional definition. If you need to consider a group of grains collectively, and they are stacked touching each other, they are a heap.
Likewise, is it a boat if you make it and never plan to put it in the water, but use it as a table? Is it a boat if you lie on a block of foam and paddle?
If you think things have some sort of platonic essence, these concepts are hard. If you think the definition of a thing is the role it fills, this particular problem is easier.
Likewise, is it a boat if you make it and never plan to put it in the water, but use it as a table? Is it a boat if you lie on a block of foam and paddle?
If you think things have some sort of platonic essence, these concepts are hard. If you think the definition of a thing is the role it fills, this particular problem is easier.