News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha... by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 19, 2016 @07:43PM (#12996611)
It doesn't represent the nullification of science; it only tries to question the basic axiom of physics that the laws of nature are the same everywhere, have always been and will always be. If you drop that axiom, consequences are interesting. If you allow for the ability of future more advanced humans to actually change some observable properties of the universe (like speed of light), then you have to allow for the possibility of past alien civilizations doing just that. And then it may turn out that what we're observing today is a universe that is not in a "virgin" state, but was affected by life in the past already.

This is a legitimate scientific question but - since we have pretty much zero evidence suggesting this has happened, we have to assume we're studying a "virgin" universe. But if physics was somehow manipulated by aliens, science should be capable of eventually figuring this out too - at the very least just because if you have a capability of doing something, then it's easier to notice evidence of someone else doing that thing in the past.

Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha... by posterboy on Sunday November 20, 2016 @08:15AM (#12998689)
That is not a physical axiom, but a logical consequence of the principle of explosion, ex contradiction sequitur quodlibet.

The fallacy here is in the assumption we had a complete idea of an immutable theory of physics, the universe and everything, when that is clearly not the case. It's the same handwavery as from theologists, as dear as it might be, that many physicists aren't or weren't free of, as well.

Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha... by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 20, 2016 @10:40AM (#12999341)
Come on. I'm simply saying that the statement "laws of physics are universal - the same everywhere, at any time" is an axiom. It's something we can't prove. We assume it for the sake of our sanity, and the assumption seems to be holding pretty well so far.
Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha... by posterboy on Sunday November 20, 2016 @11:17AM (#12999530)
>It's something we can't prove

Edit: TL;DR: An axiom is not something that is provably unprovable, it something that remains to be proved.

Yet you assume the axiom could have been proved wrong by aliens, which would give the opposite of the axiom as new universal law, which would be paradoxical. Thus, the axiom couldn't be wrong nor right, for it's not a statement, it's a paradox devoid of meaning. If that's what you implied, I might as well just be missing how that is useful. I understand that Hilbert's axioms of Geometry work the same way, so I am not dismissing the idea of axiomatics. I'm just saying that the axiom defines space and time under the presumption of an understanding of laws. Thus I think, obviously the conclusion, universal laws wouldn't exist or could be broken is rather unpractical, to put it mildly.

However, I am not (ever) sure what I am even saying. So take it with a pinch of salt. On the one hand, if axiomatics are part of our logic framework for laws, an axiom couldn't a priori define laws. On the other hand, I'm tossing the idea around for a while, that our understanding of logic arises by proving itself into existence, so we prove axiomatics a viable framework simply by using it to axiomatize.

In the likely case the the previous paragraph is written ineligibly: all I am saying is, that axioms should be self evident, so it isn't really worth the many words, except as an exercize in formalizing unfinished ideas in a dialog. Just to see if get any immediate push back, in case I am wrong, or ignorance, in case the topic is really self-evident or absurd or whatever.

Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha... by vorg on Sunday November 20, 2016 @12:51AM (#12997490)
> change some observable properties of the universe (like speed of light)

In your other comment:

> Could the speed of light have changed because of aliens weaponizing physics in past wars?

Because the speed of light is a dimensional constant, it doesn't make sense to say it could have changed in the past. Only dimensionless constants, like the fine structure constant, can hypothetically be different at other points in space and/or time. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dimensionless_physical_constan...

Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha... by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 20, 2016 @05:44AM (#12998216)
According to this article:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable_speed_of_light

the idea had some pretty serious consideration of serious scientists though.

As for dimensionless constants, the way I see it, it simply suggests that something else must be changed to get a meaningfully different c.