Re:On vagueness, or, when is a heap of sand not a heap of sand?
by woodruffw on Saturday November 19, 2016 @03:38PM
(#12995497)
I appreciate the author's dispensation with fuzzy logic as a suitable answer to the problem of the heap, but I'm not sure that his answer (a lack of knowledge) is any more persuasive.
As evidenced by his formulation of the sorites paradox, we all seem to have an intuitive notion of when a heap transitions to a less-than-heap (for lack a better word) or individual. One possible description (which I don't claim is final) that aligns with this intuition is that the whole stands out more than its parts. A heap, then, is when an object exists more on its own than as of other objects. The same might be said for crowds, flocks of birds, &c.
As evidenced by his formulation of the sorites paradox, we all seem to have an intuitive notion of when a heap transitions to a less-than-heap (for lack a better word) or individual. One possible description (which I don't claim is final) that aligns with this intuition is that the whole stands out more than its parts. A heap, then, is when an object exists more on its own than as of other objects. The same might be said for crowds, flocks of birds, &c.
Just my two cents.