Re:Gruber: Journalist Shield Law Won't Help in Gizmodo Case
by commandar on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @02:39PM
(#1299167)
Yet Gruber's been gleefully declaring Gaby Darbershire, who's an attorney with years of experience in corporate law, a hack for the last few days now.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Gruber: Journalist Shield Law Won't Help in Gizmodo Case
by pyre on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @03:19PM
(#1299346)
I think that point is that Gaby is a lawyer in the UK, not licensed to practice in the US, and probably not well-versed in California's state laws. So for her to give legal advice about how to not commit a crime in California is a little disingenuous.
Re:Gruber: Journalist Shield Law Won't Help in Gizmodo Case
by tjogin on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @03:00PM
(#1299254)
We'll see won't we? I'm betting Gruber's right. Being a journalist doesn't mean you are allowed to buy stolen goods.
Re:Gruber: Journalist Shield Law Won't Help in Gizmodo Case
by mbreese on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @03:19PM
(#1299343)
Corporate law doesn't necessarily equate with CA criminal law.
Also, I know she's a member of the bar of England and Wales, but that doesn't necessarily mean anything to the CA criminal justice system.
Then again, I too am not a lawyer.
Re:Gruber: Journalist Shield Law Won't Help in Gizmodo Case
by commandar on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @03:51PM
(#1299461)
Fair enough, I'm largely talking about Gruber doing things like comparing Darbyshire unfavorably to a drunk character from the Simpsons when the analysis I've seen from people who actually practice and teach law for a living has been far more moderate in its assessment of whether Gawker's arguments will fly or not.