Re:New CIA director thinks Snowden should be killed
by Overtonwindow on Friday November 18, 2016 @03:32PM
(#12989850)
I don't think Snowden should be killed, but I do agree he should be prosecuted and jailed for life. He committed treason. The reason is moot. I know many will disagree, but he should answer for his actions. Let a court - non-military that is - decide.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New CIA director thinks Snowden should be killed
by nickbauman on Friday November 18, 2016 @03:54PM
(#12989989)
For it to be treason evidence would have to show that Snowden acted on behalf of a foreign power. Espionage requires that Snowden acted as a spy and gave or sold secrets to another party (presumably not a foreign power or adversary). Snowden gave his vetted information to an American journalist and a British journalist. You would have a hard time making either charge actually stick. But I'm certain the US government would ruin his life thoroughly regardless.
Re:New CIA director thinks Snowden should be killed
by meowface on Saturday November 19, 2016 @01:12AM
(#12992318)
You're providing the definition for espionage, not treason. Snowden is undoubtedly guilty of treason. I think he should be pardoned or given only a light sentence, but it's definitely treason.
Re:New CIA director thinks Snowden should be killed
by thrill on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:26PM
(#12990221)
No, acting on behalf is not part of the Constitutional definition.
Re:New CIA director thinks Snowden should be killed
by logfromblammo on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:08PM
(#12990092)
If he is to be prosecuted for illegal disclosures of classified documents, let him have temporary immunity, until after the trials of all the people implicated in criminal activities by those documents.
After all, those folks committed their crimes first. He shouldn't get to jump the get-into-prison queue just because he's infamous now.
Re:New CIA director thinks Snowden should be killed
by wavefunction on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:55PM
(#12990414)
I reject the notion that someone with as much domestic support as Snowden has (admittedly not as much as he should) can be declared a traitor by some folks with a political agenda that is oppositional and actively harmful to my self and life.