News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kaspersky OS by IshKebab on Friday November 18, 2016 @06:38AM (#12986041)
Linux is very insecure. Maybe you have not been following the news lately.
Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @10:15AM (#12987267)
There's plenty of great quotes from Torvalds about why it's like that.

He places functionality over security, and assumes security will just 'happen' with code quality. I tend to disagree - but I am typing this from a Linux box, not an OpenBSD box. Because Linux is more functional as a desktop - the irony there isn't lost on me.

Re:Kaspersky OS by nickpsecurity on Friday November 18, 2016 @01:19PM (#12988830)
Exactly. Priorities = what you get out of your work. Far as Linux vs OpenBSD box, remember also that contributors (including corporate) are partly to blame here since they chose to put their investments into a project that doesn't care about security instead of one that bakes it in. Even if Theo et al weren't pleasant, they could've forked OpenBSD keeping any of their improvements while making what changes they absolutely needed. We'd have had an OpenBSD desktop in a few years as easy as OpenSUSE at the least.
Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @01:27PM (#12988919)
A very valid point. IBM contributes a TON of code to Linux. They could easily have worked to improve security if they cared.

Or, improved BSD, and avoided all that GPL stuff if they wanted.

Re:Kaspersky OS by nickpsecurity on Friday November 18, 2016 @01:37PM (#12989003)
I was actually shocked they didn't contribute to FreeBSD instead then rebrand their management or security customizations as their own enterprise OS. The Chinese ended up doing that with Kylan. Cambridge's CHERI team made it capability-secure with minimal modifications. IBM was in ideal position to do that, too, given they had legendary Paul Karger who already built high-assurance OS's and CPU's for them.

Let's just call it Another Missed Opportunity for the Big Blue. :)

Re:Kaspersky OS by mappu on Friday November 18, 2016 @05:51PM (#12990728)
> The Chinese ended up doing that with Kylan

Kylin, for others googling: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kylin_(operating_system)

It since switched to a Linux base and today powers Tianhe-1 and 2.

Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @01:41PM (#12989037)
That's a big book right there!

I was really disappointed in how Apple treated BSD, but I am stupid and naive. I would have expected that from IBM though.

Re:Kaspersky OS by grzm on Friday November 18, 2016 @01:46PM (#12989070)
"I was really disappointed in how Apple treated BSD"

Would you go into more detail here? The BSD license is very liberal. That's no excuse for bad behavior, but I'm unfamiliar with bad actions on Apple's part wrt BSD, which I gather there were given your phrasing.

Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @02:26PM (#12989380)
I don't believe they have in any way violated the letter or even spirit of the BSD license. It's extremely liberal, and should be.

However, they used to really flaunt their BSD roots on OSX, but seem to do very little to give back in the form of code, money, or even PR for that matter.

Here's an example of that: https://developer.apple.com/library/content/documentation/Da...

But now they've even removed any mention of this, and allowed projects like OpenDarwin and such to just plain die. I think it's pretty poor behavior from a company that's SO involved in intellectual property rights to just take something as valuable as a complete kernel and userland (not GUI) and then just sweep it under the carpet because no laws require them to do otherwise.

Puts a really bad taste in my mouth to see such important work treated like that. I'd have expected it from IBM, but not from Apple.

Re:Kaspersky OS by grzm on Friday November 18, 2016 @02:30PM (#12989421)
Gotcha. Thanks for taking the time to respond and fill in more of the blanks. I appreciate it.
Re:Kaspersky OS by nickpsecurity on Friday November 18, 2016 @01:55PM (#12989139)
Parent might be referring to how they just gobbled it up into Darwin and Mac OS X while contributing about nothing back. At least, I'm aware of them making a bunch of money off Mac OS X and iPhones but not hearing about contributions to FreeBSD at level IBM or Red Hat do to Linux.
Re:Kaspersky OS by grzm on Friday November 18, 2016 @02:17PM (#12989315)
Yeah, I was wondering about that, too. Granted, the BSD base is arguably one step removed from Apple (as that was NeXTSTEP, which Apple acquired), and both Darwin and OpenStep are open source. Apple continues to release the source of some of their software.[0] According to the "Myths" page at FreeBSD, "FreeBSD 9.1 and later include a C++ stack and compiler that were originally developed for OS X, with major parts of the work done by Apple employees",[1] so it hasn't completely been freeloading.

I don't know enough about the levels of contribution to either to make a strong comparison, and I'm more than willing to grant IBM and Red Hat make much larger contributions to Linux than Apple does to FreeBSD. And I sympathize with the desire to have more contributions. The "how Apple treated BSD" phrasing sounds like there is more active bad treatment rather than not contributing enough. Maybe the hiring of Jordan Hubbard is considered active bad treatment? (Honest question)

[0]: https://opensource.apple.com

[1]: https://wiki.freebsd.org/Myths#FreeBSD_is_Just_OS_X_Without_...

Re:Kaspersky OS by nickpsecurity on Friday November 18, 2016 @03:26PM (#12989804)
"so it hasn't completely been freeloading."

That's Clang/LLVM compiler that gets them off GCC's GPL codebase. It also allows them to keep more extensions proprietary if they choose. It's been beneficial to the OSS community but I'd say it's barely altruistic. An exception rather than the rule.

" The "how Apple treated BSD" phrasing sounds like there is more active bad treatment rather than not contributing enough"

Helps to remember that it's how a lack of contributions is commonly phrased. Freeloading is probably the dominant model for both users and companies far as FOSS. It's just how they word the gripe. I agree they should probably use clearer phrasing for others not deep into this subject matter.

Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @05:07PM (#12990496)
You are correct, I should have been more clear in my phrasing.
Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @02:27PM (#12989396)
Exactly - sorry, was busy :)
Re:Kaspersky OS by gribbly on Saturday November 19, 2016 @03:14AM (#12992560)
That is about the X server, which is not some Linux specific component as it is also used by all the other *nixes as well.

There is Wayland which aims to solve these security aspects mentioned in the blog post, it will be shipping by default in the next Fedora release IIRC.

Re:Kaspersky OS by at-fates-hands on Friday November 18, 2016 @09:24AM (#12986925)
But comparatively speaking is still more secure than Windows or OS X?
Re:Kaspersky OS by Aldo_MX on Friday November 18, 2016 @12:02PM (#12988168)
Depends on who you ask, for example, taking the top 50 products with new vulnerabilities discovered in 2016[1], Windows 10 got less vulnerabilities than the Linux Kernel and OS X.

This could either mean that Windows 10 has become more secure than its most popular competitors, or that researchers hadn't invested enough resources to audit Windows 10 properly.

Taking into account the results from previous years and previous versions (like 8.1), my personal conclusion is that Windows has actually become more secure.

[1] https://www.cvedetails.com/top-50-products.php?year=2016

Re:Kaspersky OS by Vendan on Friday November 18, 2016 @12:35PM (#12988423)
Well, there's also how serious the vulnerabilities are. Linux kernel had 4 code execution vulns, Windows 10 had 44. Linux had 44 gain privilege vulns, Windows 10 had 79. Linux seemed to have mostly DoS vulns, which is admittedly not great, but I'd rather a server go down then get compromised and used to take over the rest of the network. Then there's the fun stuff, like mimikatz, that's been around since windows XP and still can pull passwords from windows 10...
Re:Kaspersky OS by Aldo_MX on Friday November 18, 2016 @02:12PM (#12989276)
It is expected that the smallest attack surface will have less critical vulnerabilities, comparing an entire distro gives you a different picture, since categories like code execution get similar results.

The stark contrast is in the privilege escalation vulnerabilities from the Windows side vs the other categories on the Linux side.

I would assume that many persons prefer a server to go down, corrupt its data and leak it, rather than get compromised. The fine print is that the leaked data may contain information to compromise the server[1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heartbleed

Re:Kaspersky OS by Vendan on Friday November 18, 2016 @03:55PM (#12989996)
Yeah, but now you swung in the opposite direction. Look at Debian Linux's 2016 code exec vulns and you'll see it's got a like Firefox and Chrome and Drupal and Mercurial... not exactly OS components... whereas the windows 10 vulns are are windows OS components. I'd personally be curious if any of those "debian vulns" would be equally applicable to the same software installed on windows.
Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @10:16AM (#12987280)
The biggest issue with Windows isn't its inherent security, it's the way it's used. Most users run everything with super admin rights. Most developers require that for installs.

OSX is right behind it, with a culture of laxness that undoes most of the benefits the designers tried to give them.

Re:Kaspersky OS by Vendan on Friday November 18, 2016 @12:36PM (#12988436)
I've run into "security software" for domain computers that required every computer to have the same local admin password... and for it to be enabled on every computer.
Re:Kaspersky OS by krylon on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:52PM (#12990388)
Hehe, I once saw a corporate network where the root password on all Un*x systems was ${vendor}xyz, i.e. sunxyz for a Solaris box, ibmxyz for AIX, and so forth. I hope at least they disabled root login via ssh.
Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @05:06PM (#12990487)
I've not seen that, but I have seen one where the root password was the vendor who supported it - like capgem123 ibm123 etc.

Not quite as bad, but still pretty weak.

Re:Kaspersky OS by this-dang-guy on Friday November 18, 2016 @01:08PM (#12988723)
Exactly. That's ridiculous thinking far beyond what the OS designer is responsible for.
Re:Kaspersky OS by ksk on Friday November 18, 2016 @12:23PM (#12988328)
What do you mean by secure? What kinds of OS functions and capabilities do you consider the purview of an OS from a security standpoint?