Re:Why Is Apple's iPhone Prototype Entitled To More Justice?
by chc on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @02:44PM
(#1299185)
If we use this logic, we must conclude that it is more acceptable in the state's eyes (or at least the state wants everybody to think it is more acceptable) to murder children than to take photos of a prototype phone. This is an extremely disturbing case if your suggested reasoning is correct.
Re:Why Is Apple's iPhone Prototype Entitled To More Justice?
by anigbrowl on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @03:59PM
(#1299490)
No more than we must conclude two HN comments from different posters represent yCombinator's corporate viewpoint.
Re:Why Is Apple's iPhone Prototype Entitled To More Justice?
by chc on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @04:51PM
(#1299680)
That's not similar, because we are not representatives of HN. Government employees using their authority do represent the government.
Re:Why Is Apple's iPhone Prototype Entitled To More Justice?
by anigbrowl on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @07:46PM
(#1300219)
Which government? We have thousands of them in US, in case you hadn't noticed. My point is that 'the state' is not a monolithic entity, and the comparison of two different crimes in different jurisdictions in different decades doesn't mean anything very much.
If some random phone gets lost obviously you aren't going to spend too much resources on this because there aren't enough available. I'm pretty sure not all such individual cases are ignored, so it's not like only the corporations "receive justice".
But, having such a public case about a presumably lost prototype, etc. be ignored is a sign that the state considers this to be ok or of low importance. You do not want that idea to spread into the mainstream. Justice isn't just about busting dors, it's also a marketing (or propaganda) issue.