News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by sophacles on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:39AM (#1298557)
There is also the absurd death threat/possible murder-as-retribution aspect. I will gladly mock people who think killing is a viable response to an image, even if it is offensive.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by johnyzee on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:51AM (#1298598)
Except this is offensive to even the Muslims who are perfectly reasonable.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by MartinCron on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:10PM (#1298668)
As Philip Pullman so beautifully said (about Christianity, in his case) nobody has the right to never be offended.

Video here: http://onegoodmove.org/1gm/1gmarchive/2010/04/philip_pullman...

Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by foldr on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:49PM (#1298798)
Nobody's suggesting that Muslims have a right not to be offended. The point is just that deliberately offending a large group of people is usually a dick move.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by MartinCron on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:04PM (#1298847)
Sure, it's a dick move, but it shouldn't be a crime, let alone a capital crime. Having dicks around is just a price you have to pay to have a free society.

To mangle a quote from Voltaire, "I may not like that dick move, but I'll fight to the death for your right to be a dick like that"

Update: I don't mean to paint everyone who doesn't like this as wanting to make it against the law. I personally don't like this, just as I don't like flag burning, but I do like and appreciate the fact that it can be done.

Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by foldr on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:07PM (#1298857)
Nobody's saying that it should be a crime, either. They're just saying that it's not a good idea to do it.

It's kind of silly that you can't argue against this without people assuming that you're in favor of criminalizing the cartoons. You can disapprove of something without wanting there to be a law against it.

Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by pw0ncakes on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:30PM (#1298727)
I agree. Obviously, people have the right to depict Mohammed however they wish. Whether they necessarily should is another matter. Offensiveness for its own sake is the province of the Manhattan "high art" world, but (being outside of that world) I don't buy into it as a good thing.

I thought South Park was harmless and funny in its 200th and 201st episodes, because the poignancy-to-offensiveness ratio was high (they were pretty inoffensive in their treatment of Islam).

What's odd and somewhat inconsistent here is that Islam doesn't forbid only the depiction of Mohammed, but of any of God's creations (defined as the animals including humans). This aversion to depiction isn't rare in human cultures; Renaissance-era Christians considered theatre morally impure and actors were refused Catholic burials at one time.

Yet, as far as I know, few Muslims are offended when non-Muslims create cartoons in general, even though strict Muslims aren't allowed to do so. Yet when Mohammed is involved, it's considered to be on a different level.

Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by MartinCron on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:20PM (#1298894)
Interesting trivia from the good micro-history book "The Immortal Game" is that the classic stylized chess piece shapes that are still used today were adapted from more representative figures specifically to be less offensive to Muslim leaders who didn't approve of the realistic depictions.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by sophacles on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:04PM (#1298648)
Too bad for them? Being offended is not the end of the world. I'm offended every time some tea-party person claims that * is tantamount to nazi-ism, but I don't threaten death as a response, and I would probably mock anyone who did.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by Kadin on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:01PM (#1298638)
I don't see how that's possible. It's not reasonable to get offended because of a harmless cartoon; anyone who does is by definition unreasonable.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by JabavuAdams on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:16PM (#1298687)
Suppose we're talking in person. In the middle of the conversation, I fart. Then I pick my nose and eat it. Finally I reach into my pants and scratch my crotch.

All of these things are harmless to you, but I would not be surprised if you were offended by some of them.

Disgust is cultural.

It's important to recognize that large numbers of people can as a result of their culture be disgusted by things we consider normal. It's unreasonable to say "you shouldn't be disgusted".

The best we can say is that the value of free speech outweighs the value of pandering to various groups' definitions of good taste.

Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by Kadin on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:53PM (#1298811)
Disgust and offense are very different things. There are many things that I find disgusting, yet I am not offended by them since they don't affect me.

I can think of a lot of sexual practices that strike me as really disgusting. Eating shit, for instance. Yet the fact that people out there do it doesn't offend me; being forced (or tricked) into watching it would be, but the act itself is merely disgusting. It becomes offensive when it's forced. To be offended, particularly to the point of violent action, over something that doesn't affect you (or any other person, or even an animal) strikes me as unreasonable.

Of course, since you've opened up the rabbit hole of cultural constructs I'll admit that "reasonableness" is cultural as well -- but I think the Western, Enlightenment-inspired idea of "reason" and "reasonableness" is worth fighting for. If that makes me a cultural imperialist, so be it.

Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by sigzero on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:10PM (#1298866)
I am 100% sure that I would not threaten to kill you for any of those things.
Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by ErrantX on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:50PM (#1299002)
No and neither would the vast majority of Muslims.

(bearing in mind that this was a discussion about why Muslims take offence at the cartoons and their response. I may have misread but the above poster seems to suggest that Muslims generally give death threats over this offence - which is untrue. The extremist is giving the threats not the Muslim :-))

Re:Seattle cartoonist launches "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" by jbooth on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @12:46PM (#1298786)
Which "people", exactly? "Muslims"?