Re:Britain passed the “most extreme surveillance law ever pa...
by dracht on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:56PM
(#12981464)
I've noticed that Britons, generally speaking, put a lot of trust in authority. They'll shrug it off or rationalize it when their government introduces another perverted law - the NHS works, so it can't be that bad, surely. Britain lacks a sizeable and vocal government-distrusting counterculture like they exist in Germany or the US. How you go about introducing that artificially, I don't know. The frog is being boiled too slowly.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Britain passed the “most extreme surveillance law ever pa...
by vacri on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:09PM
(#12981591)
Ah, yes. The US, where you don't have so much surveillance... but cops can just take your money because they feel like it. British police also follow the Peelian principles, so they do fewer things like send SWAT teams to batter down people's doors and point guns at innocents.
I'm not really seeing how US government application of authority is better than the UK's on the basis of a vocal citizenry.
Re:Britain passed the “most extreme surveillance law ever pa...
by bjelkeman-again on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:18PM
(#12982720)
That is interesting. Living in Sweden, and having lived in the UK for 15 years, I feel the Brits trust their government much less than the Swedes do. In the UK there is strong resistance against a national ID card, as an example. Whereas in Sweden you can hardly live without one.
I got the feeling that the Brits didn't trust their government with that info and control it implies. In Sweden we have the opposite: ID cards are seen as an asset and surveillance cameras are severely restricted by the government, for privacy reasons.
Re:Britain passed the “most extreme surveillance law ever pa...
by nly on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:32PM
(#12982832)
Resistance to the national ID card idea mostly came down to two things 1) cost to government, and 2) cost to citizens.
There's also the fact that ~87% of the population already hold a passport, and some of those that don't likely have a drivers license.
Re:Britain passed the “most extreme surveillance law ever pa...
by bjelkeman-again on Sunday November 20, 2016 @05:10AM
(#12998138)
The funny thing is that the cost to the individual is negligible and the cost to government (and business) is low compared to the benefits. Less fraud, efficient identification processes etc.
Re:Britain passed the “most extreme surveillance law ever pa...
by westiseast on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:23PM
(#12983806)
I think we're fairly moderate people in general, so it's not so much excessive trust as just some kind of tacit understanding that things won't go to extremes because we're British (and also a tendency to avoid extreme reactions). I guess sometimes that's dangerous because there's a faslse sense of security, but perhaps there's other benefits to that.