News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UEFI boot: how does that actually work, then? (2014) by mindslight on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:36PM (#12981257)
> Maybe that's the difference between the (for lack of a better term) BSD philosophy vs. RMS

I like your characterization of this, but keep in mind you're proceeding to apply a moral dimension here ;)

> I wonder if an individual's preference of copyleft vs. permissive is correlated with whether they think humans are inherently evil, vs. humans being inherently good or neutral. As cynical and pessimistic as I feel about humanity sometimes, deep down I do have a conviction that people are inherently good.

Most people have an internal narrative whereby they are doing good, yet we still get emergent evil behavior. I tend to look at good/evil in terms of describing constructive end results, rather than as intent behind individual actions.

Pragmatically, I'm seeing an awful lot of Free software that has been locked down through one scheme or another, making it non-Free for its end users. Since the intention of at least some of this software was to be Free for end users, I'd say nullifying that goal is moving in an evil direction.

While fewer restrictions is indeed "simpler", such a regime isn't necessarily sufficient to achieve certain goals. When something is existentially defined as "base primitives", complexity will build on top of it to undermine the goals that fostered the axioms. Only by defining universal quantifications on behavior can specific qualities be preserved through time.

There are no comments on this comment yet.