News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Books Programmers Don't Really Read by tptacek on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @07:27AM (#1297852)
Couldn't disagree more about TAOCP. I haven't finished any of them, but I think they recommend themselves poorly as references and are brilliant front-to-back readers. Every time I make a couple hours for them, no matter where in which book I start, I learn something new. TAOCP is in that sense more like the Bible than the dictionary.

That the examples are in "assembly language" is a red herring, since the machine the book targets is deliberately simplified. The "assembly" is just a notation. The idea, which seems to be to make the examples as concrete as possible, is beginner-friendly --- as anyone who's been tripped up by mistakes and ambiguities in older Sedgewick books can attest.

Re:Books Programmers Don't Really Read by mahmud on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @08:18AM (#1297935)
Grab the fasciscle (sp?) 1 of Volume 4; the bitmanipulation stuff reads like poetry.
Re:Books Programmers Don't Really Read by akkartik on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:51PM (#1299003)
Re:Books Programmers Don't Really Read by imurray on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:19PM (#1298886)
fascicle
Re:Books Programmers Don't Really Read by Agathos on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @08:27PM (#1300296)
"I consider it amazing that some people do go cover to cover in my books. In most cases I know that people are going to pick and choose the parts that they like. But they know that if they dig further then they'll get something that has only one subset of jargon describing it instead of all different kinds of notations and terminology -- if I didn't write the books it would be much harder for people to find stuff out. That's what turns me on."

--Knuth, in Coders at Work

Re:Books Programmers Don't Really Read by tptacek on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @08:44PM (#1300330)
Like I said, it's like the Bible. Most people don't cover-to-cover the Bible. But the Bible also isn't the "encyclopedia of Catholicism". People have favorite passages. There are books in it people do read end to end. There are places, like Psalms, where you open to an arbitrary page and read either direction.

TAOCP is like that.

Re:Books Programmers Don't Really Read by jgg on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @02:17PM (#1299088)
I agree. At first glance, their length makes it appear to be a reference work, but when you look at his writing style and the exercises at the end of each section, it seems quite clear that he intended otherwise.

That being said, I haven't finished the series.