Speaking only for myself, I was enamored by VCs when I first moved to the Bay Area. I definitely put them up on a pedestal, and selectively listened to people who did the same. After spending about 12 months trying to raise money for my "business guy w/ no traction & no product" startup idea, I learned that VCs are highly visible & accessible because they need to generate leads for themselves. But I didn't understand for quite a while that I was bringing them a lead they would never fund. That was a hard lesson to learn.
However, at the same time, the cargo culting creates inefficiencies and a lot of group pressure which forces companies to conform to the metrics du jour to raise funds. From a vantage point outside of the industry, these metrics feel almost memetic in nature. It seems that a lot of these hoops exist because other people have used these set of hoops before, therefore they must be valid in some shape or form. It's a recursive sort of logic whereby the rationale behind an investment metric is reinforced by the social signals around it. Plus, I'm sure that it doesn't help that most VCs don't actually have a quant styled background and most VCs don't model their investments in any shape or form. (while the modeling may not be accurate - it is still a useful tool for thinking through investments)
Of course all of this is actually an opportunity for the enterprising VC. A smart VC firm could theoretically create a better, more quantitative process and pick up unconventional companies for cheaper and get better returns as a result.
edit: Just in case it wasn't clear, I'm not accusing the OP of cargo culting - it's rather the opposite. It's more of a meta-observation / addendum to his observations.