I've always thought the problem with the major economic systems isn't that either of them is inherently flawed, just that they haven't really even been implemented in a large enough scale for any decent period of time. In America we pay socialist taxes and get capitalist benefits, that's the problem. We have to pick one and commit to it.
There used to be a 'free market' it was called 'feudalism'.
Not quite, but almost.
If you believe in 'Adam Smith' then you understand under a totally free system, one person would end up with all the wealth.
Adam Smith was not a libertarian, or a 'laissez faire' kind of dude. He was an Ethicist and heavy duty Christian and to him capitalism was a moral issue.
Unlike the 'Chicago School' and Libertarian types who really state that corps exist for the shareholders, that's it, end of story.
As noted above, Smith invented progressive taxation.
Get this - do you know what Smith said the #1 quality of a CEO is?
Get this: 'Benevolence'
Not something you'd hear too often in America.
Onerous regulation is obviously a problem, and wasted taxation inefficient government is also a problem.
But there's no doubt they have to exist.
There's a 99.9% chance you'd be a serf were there to be a truly free and open, 'laissez faire' market. You wouldn't even have a chance at going to a good Uni. You know Trump's son-in-law, Kushner? He only got into Harvard after his parents gave $2.5M to the school. Maybe 1/3 Harvard students buy they way in. In a totally capitalist system, 100% of top spots would be 'bought' - industrialists want to ensure their legacy, and that their kids get into the top schools, and that would guarantee the longevity of their Empire.
Anyhow, that taxes can be too high and spent inefficiently does not mean they should not exit.
It describes Supply and Demand in a mechanical way, illustrates the power of comparative value, the 'invisible hand' etc..
Smith was a Ethicist and a heavy duty Christian, and so he also realized how the system could be imbalanced, and definitely took the concerns of the plebes to heart etc..
But by no means was this a social treatise, or an attempt to validate social theory or 'socialism' (which didn't really exist).
And I think your comment about Scotland/UK is not true at all.
The 'Supply and Demand' bit that Krugman said 'all econs agree on' is really from Adam Smith.
Marx basically evaluated that in the context of the fact that some small group apparently had all the capital, while others had none, which creates an inherent power/class struggle and so it turns into a political issue.
Smith and Marx probably would have agreed on 'the problem' though almost surely not the solution :)