News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by saosebastiao on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @02:31PM (#12970562)
It's quite possibly the least poignant and lowest-common-denominator populist cliche I've ever read. It's like describing Computer Science as the study of how to make Flappy Bird clones and To Do apps.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by myowncrapulence on Friday November 18, 2016 @08:49PM (#12991540)
Tell me more about the justification for arbitrarily low interest-rates for banks at an all-time market high. Tell me more about how helicopter money QE is justified being put into circulation when wages are stagnant.

You obviously are an economist who has an extreme biased.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by saosebastiao on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:18PM (#13000203)
Macroeconomics represents less than 20% of the practitioners of economics as a profession. Of those macroeconomists, maybe 5% actively involve themselves in business cycle theory, and only a fraction of those would fall into the monetarist theory camp which would advocate for such interventions. So even your absolutely idiotic straw man argument concerns at most a fraction of 1% of the practitioners of economics.

And no, I'm not an economist with "an extremely biased [sic]". I'm a supply chain engineer that has directly worked with dozens of economists for approximately 3 years, incorporated dozens of their econometric models into supply chain decision systems, and have never once have discussed anything political with them. And I just witnessed a clueless bullshitter malign the field of study that they have dedicated their lives to with an argument that could be considered libel at its most forgiving interpretation, and decided to call that clueless bullshitter out on it.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by rhizome on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:27PM (#12971143)
It's like describing Computer Science as the study of how to make Flappy Bird clones and To Do apps.

In practice? It's a little bit true. How many CS grads work at companies roughly in the sectors you mention? How many want to?

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by rifung on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @04:30PM (#12971745)
> How many CS grads work at companies roughly in the sectors you mention?

What a field is or is not about is not determined by what graduates of said field do or want to do post graduation.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by rhizome on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:32PM (#12982368)
I didn't claim an iron law of meaning, I said it's "a little bit true." It was my attempt at making a nuanced, if short, observation.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by metaphorm on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @05:32PM (#12972237)
so what determines what a field is, or is not, about if we cannot consider what the practicioners of that field do in their professional lives?
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by icebraining on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @06:30PM (#12972630)
They are not practitioners of the field, they're just people who happen to have a degree in that field. One of my coworkers has a degree in chemistry, yet she works in accounting, does that mean that the field of chemistry is defined by accounting? Yes, SW development is closer to CS, but it's still a separate endeavor.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by metaphorm on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @07:49PM (#12973168)
if you friend worked in pharmaceuticals development you'd have a better analogy.

theory and application BOTH define the field. it's an unfortunate tendency in academia to claim that _only_ the research/theory part is the field.