1) if you wanted to launch an attack, how better than to buy a few VPSes in Russia. This is like saying that an attack that originated in AWS US-EAST was undertaken by the US Government. Truly bizarre.
2) The person who did that is apparently more of a pundit than an official.
3) Not sure what evidence you'd point to for this. Assange did an interview for hire than was run on RT, but surely he would happily do interviews with American TV networks if they offered.
4) Trump made a PR stunt remark about respecting Putin and the next thing we all know he's a Russian stooge. Not sure how old you are but during the cold war it was a big relief when Reagan and Gorbachev sat down for talks and everyone calmed down. In light of the frantic anti-Russian rhetoric coming from HRC's political campaign, I view any sort of moderation as a breath of fresh air and sign of maturity.
I think the disturbing issue is that we don't have enough transparency into the DOJ, the FBI or the NSA to have any clue what might be going on. There was pretty much zero reaction/reform after the Snowden revelations. I would not have thought this possible.
The solution is for the NSA to share their evidence to a third party and the third party to come forward saying, "yup, I've seen the evidence and it is clear and irrefutable". I believe congress/senate are usually that third party, but for something technical like this I think they would benefit from inviting someone like Bruce Schneier to those sessions.
Will it happen. No. But, should it happen? Yes. Especially if there are to be escalations.
But I agree wholeheartedly: the first and foremost purpose of the NSA should be securing the USA's IT infrastructure.
This doesn't even hint that there might be Russian involvement. It's utterly irrelevant. Anyone doing something like this will most likely be hosting either in Russia or the Netherlands.
>2) Pseudo-admission/gloating by low-level officials
Low-level officials probably aren't in positions to confirm intelligence operations such as these, and even if they were, such behaviour would hardly be unexpected from an entirely unrelated party.
>3) Wikileaks and Assange's increasingly close relationship with Russia
Would you like to back that up somehow? Not all of us share your security clearance so we can't read the emails between Assange and Putin.
>4) The behavior of the Trump campaign, taking an exceptionally pro-Russian tack. Indeed, the only change they demanded be made to the Republican platform was to take out some anti-Russian commitments.
The pro-Russian tack only stands out if you ignore the rest of their politics... In which case literally anything would stand out, no?
>True, this is all circumstantial
This is all bullshit. There exists significantly better technical evidence of Russian involvement available to the public.
Could you share?
> we can't read the emails between Assange and Putin.
Perhaps some person or organization that believes in radical transparency will leak them.I'm not bringing this point up to start a side tangent argument, but just pointing out that in this election cycle, a lot of people held pre-existing beliefs and would justify them in any way they could (i.e. cognitive dissonance).
As it stands, the public evidence I've seen is
1) The attacks originating from servers owned by Russian companies
2) Pseudo-admission/gloating by low-level officials
3) Wikileaks and Assange's increasingly close relationship with Russia
4) The behavior of the Trump campaign, taking an exceptionally pro-Russian tack. Indeed, the only change they demanded be made to the Republican platform was to take out some anti-Russian commitments.
True, this is all circumstantial. The NSA certainly has more. If the NSA released it, the people who disbelieve the NSA would rightly point out that any really hard evidence could have been planted by the NSA anyway, so it can't be taken as certain that the NSA didn't plant it.
So why should the NSA sacrifice any assets to satisfy them?