News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not Even In South Park? by ErrantX on Monday April 26, 2010 @07:01PM (#1296532)
> I just drew Mohammed on a napkin. Do you think I should pay a fine, go to jail, something?...

You know that's not what I mean :) and it's unrelated. Also your definition of blame is fallacious because punishment does not always take the form of jail/fine (i.e. social blame, personal blame).

Besides your action is not inciting; who will see it? If you now go into the town centre and happen to post it near a mosque athat has potential to be inciting. And you need to consider whether that is the sensible thing to do.

(the answer is; it's probably fine because no one is likely to get killed)

> then tell me how can I know, prior to expressing my thoughts, if my work will result in a murder.

Strawman; there is ample precedent for media, particularly cartoons, to cause offence and elicit extremist response.

> You're being vague if you say "some people, long history, napkim is okay, cartoon in national newspaper is not". I want to be a law abiding citizen. Should the government publish a list of prohibited things to say?

Deliberately so; it's a personal choice, not something anyone else should decide!

> I don't think you've thought this one through.

You skirt around some good points - particularly with regards to "social interference" (i.e. a moral brigade deciding what is right/wrong to publish based on their feeling on what will cause extremist response). However I think you make a few fatal mistakes in rhetoric (mostly by building on increasingly shaking links); ultimately I'm not sure you've thought the counter argument through clearly.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by inerte on Monday April 26, 2010 @07:17PM (#1296578)
Just to let you know I think we're in a point where the medium doesn't help either one of us to convince the other of anything, so I really would have some additional stuff to say (I do have the modern judicial system on my side, after all ;)) but I'm going to choose not do it right now, here on this board. Agree to disagree?
Re:Not Even In South Park? by ErrantX on Monday April 26, 2010 @07:20PM (#1296585)
Heh, yeh good reminder.. I actually never thought it would spurn such a big thread. My fault.

I suspect I've just not really put my idea out there very well. It happens.

> Agree to disagree?

Done.