Re:The Most Effective Weapon on the Modern Battlefield Is Co...
by angersock on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @08:14PM
(#12963797)
I don't know if this matches your experience, but in theory you can deploy a big line of Hescos all at once:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPuw-f8JMTw
> Although it wouldn't surprise me if the pentagon somehow managed to airlift these barriers from the US to Iraq to be deployed in Baghdad instead of just contracting the local concrete factories.
What, pay hundreds of thousands of dollars and countless gallons of fuel to transport big concrete blocks across the world? Our DoD? Surely you jest. 8)
Re:The Most Effective Weapon on the Modern Battlefield Is Co...
by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @08:50PM
(#12963933)
Well that's a cool thing, but no never seen that being used tbh, while it's fast, it also means you need some extra things, which also means planning ;)
This is more in line with how usually these things are deployed. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_lsmE_EwEE
If it's more organized it's usually means it's deployed by the engineering corps or a contractor anyhow.
Re:The Most Effective Weapon on the Modern Battlefield Is Co...
by hexane360 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:58PM
(#12964634)
The perfect harmless prank: deploying a shipping container of Hescos in a densely populated area.
Re:The Most Effective Weapon on the Modern Battlefield Is Co...
by techdragon on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:23PM
(#12964519)
That's a pretty great way to deploy empty barriers, but what I'd love to see is a machine to fill them even a quarter as fast as they can deploy them haha
They are also slower to deploy, tho if you do it properly you dig both the obstacle outer ditch (which makes the effective height of barrier too high to scale) and trenches as you fill them since the ground needs to come from somewhere.
That said to deploy concrete barriers you need a crane, when push comes to shove a squad with shovels can fill a hesco.
Some concrete barriers can also be higher than hescos, tho you can stack hescos without much trouble.
Overall if you are building an FOB all you need is a few flatbed trucks and a bobcat (small earth mover) to pretty quickly deploy hescos, concrete barriers need heavy trucks (which also means proper roads, you won't be driving a truck filled with concrete barriers over soft terrain) and you actually need engineers (as in the military definition, not academically educated ones) to deploy them.
In an urban environment concrete can make more sense tho, you can't dig ditched to increase the height, can't dig up the ground randomly, and since concrete barriers are thinner they are more easily deployed in urban environments and it's not like you have issues with logistics.
Although it wouldn't surprise me if the pentagon somehow managed to airlift these barriers from the US to Iraq to be deployed in Baghdad instead of just contracting the local concrete factories.