"random mutation is an important element in evolution, but less important than the process of natural selection, which is not random at all"
So their point is that random mutation occurs but is then filtered non-randomly, like a high-pass filter on noise. It's still a bit of an overstatement to say "not random at all" since there is obviously some (bad) luck in "fit" individuals dying or "unfit" individuals surviving. In the long-run though, you can see their point.
They go on to make a ridiculous claim that because you are here, nothing random happened to your ancestors. I would say it's just one possible history, and perhaps everyone makes mistakes with randomness.
How about if you filter every digit that is not exactly one more than the last unfiltered digit?
This seems to lead to a meaningless/useless definition paradox. 'Randomness' comes to mean everything and nothing. This is one of the things that led me away from an interest in the materialist/physicalist position. Like you said elsewhere, it seems hard to swallow the idea that all that we can achieve in defining 'randomness' is a negative definition. Personally, I find it problematic that materialism has no positive definition of what 'randomness' is and does not seem capable of offering a meaningful/useful definition.
I doubt you'll find any better usage of randomness in other fields, and in many ways, "random" is used to censor things our theories can't represent, and wrap them in stochastic approximators. This is useful, because we can then use the stochastic models as a bound on the possible outcomes caused by things we can't model (for various reasons). This let's us calculate useful predictions involving things we don't or can't know.
I don't think randomness is a negative definition, just that our primary usage of the concept is boxing up unmodelable things.
Nietzsche's "eternal return" posited just this type of situation, a limited (though huge) amount of stuff, and a limitless amount of time, well with those two you'd relive your life an eternal amount of times, presumably.
As an aside, I personally find a warming way of thinking of this idea by fictionalizing it to imagine that "I" might live a future life of every other person and even animal. Maybe by thinking like this I will be more likely to treat them as ends in themselves, and not as a means to an end, that's to say, closer to Kant's "categorical imperative". That would be nice.
From a Newtonian/Classical perspective - yes.
But we're at quantum physics now - so no.
Every single particle interaction is basically 'inherently random'.
Also - what you are saying would apply to 'us' as well, that we are all deterministic ... again, because we're living quantum (as far as we know) - no, it's random.
Purely random is where materialism stands now.
I should add that materialism is just one metaphysical presupposition.
From a Newtonian/Classical perspective - yes.
Well, maybe not! It's possible that indeterminism may be found in classical mechanics; the classic example is Norton's Dome, discussed in [1] with another reference in [2]. If you read [1], you'll see that there isn't yet any general agreement as to why its paradox is invalid. That's a potentially fruitful avenue for research, methinks.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norton%27s_dome
[2] http://hsm.stackexchange.com/questions/2678/history-of-the-s...
I completely agree that the classical determinism I mentioned also applies to us. One of my questions is whether and then how and then to what degree the randomness from quantum events can allow free will and then free action.
So, I wonder how much quantum randomness affects things. For example, atomic clocks face indeterminacy but are all the same the most accurate clocks we have, by far. Of course, once you add things like eternities, this can surely get very different... But 13 billion years is very far from an eternity...
Also I do understand that materialism is only one of many metaphysical suppositions. But it's the one that we can seem to do the most with. Hard to do much with metaphysical idealism, for example...
Anyway I'm no scientist or mathematician or philosopher so I'm out of my depth here. I'd be interested in your thoughts though. Thanks ~~
But I see your point about how some macro-level things seem to be that way.
This is wrong. A random process (gene mutation), within a randomly changing environment - is a 'net random process'.
The author tricked himself.
The purely physical/materialist perspective does have this paradox: we're just purely random bags of particles, and there actually cannot be any such thing as 'intelligence' or 'life' or 'love' or 'language' - just the appearance of it.
If you throw a bag of a trillion^trillion^trillion particles into a purely self contained environment (i.e. the Universe), and let it stir for a while - whatever is going on - at least from a materialist perspective - is random.
Scientists realize this and there's a new field of thought called 'emergence' which at least tries to grapple with it 'one step' away from materialism, and they toy with the idea that properties of complex entities may 'emerge' independent of their more simplistic constituent parts.