News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by dandare on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:15PM (#12954552)
I think this is one of the good ideas that pave the way to hell. What is fake and what is truth? How is Google going to decide? Couple examples: 1/ Is global warming a huge conspiracy? The president of USA certainly says so. 2/ News: CIA plotted with terrorist to traffic drugs to US - that must be a hoax, right? 3/ News: The US govt secretly spread syphilis among black population - this infowars shit must be surely hoax. 4/ How about US pretending being attacked to start a war? I am talking about Gulf of Tonkin, not 9/11. 5/ The government is reading all your emails and listening to all your phonecalls - bat shit crazy, right?

What I am trying to say is that once such mechanism is in place it can go on a slippery slope from there on. Next thing they will decide to filter fake news search results and that very minute they will be subpoenaed to hide something in the name of state security.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by toomuchtodo on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:30PM (#12954637)
> What I am trying to say is that once such mechanism is in place it can go on a slippery slope from there on. Next thing they will decide to filter fake news search results and that very minute they will be subpoenaed to hide something in the name of state security.

This thread makes me deeply nervous thinking about tech giants turning into the Ministry Of Truth.

EDIT: As tech professions, do we not appreciate the scale, reach, and leverage technology provides? If we do recognize that, we must realize that with great power comes great responsibility.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by TAForObvReasons on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:38PM (#12954675)
> Tech giants turning into the Ministry Of Truth

That already happened. According to a 2014 survey [1], about 64% of American adults "use" facebook and about 30% of the American adult population get their news from Facebook. Think about that for a moment. Facebook really has an incredible reach.

[1] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/09/24/how-social-m...

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by baybal2 on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:38PM (#12954681)
>primary purpose of the web property,"

Clickfarm like other 9 out of 10 news websites

Well, I wish Googlers luck. Clickfarmers, botters, and runners of industrialised clickbait networks will always be a step ahead of them.

Whitehat anti-botting people are a mirror image of people who develop and sell "anti-virus" software.

Not only they have a profit motive to do their shıtty job poorly, they are simply not in the same class intellectually

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by matt4077 on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:22PM (#12954592)
I know there are people who will dismiss it as bias, but you can actually assign a quality score to publications quite easily. NYT/Wall Street Journal/The Atlantic/Guardian/Washington Post/The New Yorker vs. breitbart/HuffPost/....

Note that all those stories you're referencing were all broken by the papers I listed. The breitbarts of the world usually just repackage what actual news organizations publish with ideological slant.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by myowncrapulence on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:49PM (#12954733)

  Note that all those stories you're referencing were all broken by the papers I listed.
Actually, Snowden was turned down by every single newspaper you just listed with the exception of The Guardian.
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by matt4077 on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:58PM (#12955713)
Wasn't it NYT/Guardian/SPIEGEL that released simultaneously? Also note that he chose to work with these organizations, even though he could have easily posted it online/given it to wikileaks.
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by myowncrapulence on Friday November 18, 2016 @08:59PM (#12991577)
No, they published later after The Guardian and The Washington Post had already covered a majority of the leaks.
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by bcoates on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:50PM (#12954741)
The Atlantic doesn't deserve to be nearly that high; they're a Vox-tier (sub-HuffPo) advertorial garbage house monentizing out the last gasp of their dead brand's reputation.

To complicate your linear model of news quality, the National Enquirer routinely publishes batshit nonsense ("Rafael Cruz murdered JFK" and "Scalia was assassinated by a hooker", recently) and has also broken several major real stories nobody else would touch.

The Graunaid is even harder to fit on your line; decent-quality and mostly worth reading agitprop from an unapologetically specific slant that rejects objective truth as some sort of bourgeoisie conspiracy. The only thing worse than ignoring them is believing them uncritically.

Bias itself is a bad model; everyone's slanted, not everyone is worth reading.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by thrden on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:33PM (#12954651)
It's worth noting that the "respectable" news organizations that you listed repackage associated press or reuters stories.
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by matt4077 on Monday November 14, 2016 @09:52PM (#12955248)
Yes, I thought about adding those, then forgot. They're obviously quality news sources. I know there's a lot of criticism of newspapers using agencies, but not for a lack of quality. (And criticizing their use is also a bit questionable – it's kinda like criticizing programmers for using libraries, and nobody has an idea for a business model that works without them)
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by tomsaffell on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:33PM (#12954650)
>repackage what actual news organizations publish with ideological slant.

Which is what The Economist does - it's been doing so since 1843. Current circulation is over one million, and it's widely respected, though not by all...

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by matt4077 on Monday November 14, 2016 @10:05PM (#12955292)
There's a bit of a difference in that the actual facts in the Economist are probably trustworthy, but I agree that they argue from a certain (free-market worshipping) point-of-view.

It's obviously a scale, and opinions will vary widely. It's not even a problem for journalism to have an opinion (I'd actually argue it's impossible). What readers should demand is a good-faith effort to argue the best version of the opposition's case.

At this point, the problem with the US right isn't actually ideology. You can believe that coal is the future, and I'll vote against you, but I'm not looking at CDC statistics to find out when I can expect you to die. It's the complete disregard for the system that's alarming. All over the country, there are polling places, often staffed by the older generation, people from both parties and independents, and the ones I've met always gave me the feeling that they'd defend the integrity of the vote no matter what. I wish I could say the same about the people being elected.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by notahacker on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:41PM (#12954691)
tbh, I don't think it's Breitbart/HuffPo's that this is trying to disassociate it from

It's the likes of sites so disreputable they have to pretend to be Breitbart, like the Breitbartt.co site which was one of the sources for Denzel Washington's huge, if true (not true) endorsement of Donald Trump that was among Facebook's top trending stories recently.

The cynic in me suspects this is at least as much about pointing an accusing finger at social media platforms for not getting their house in order as getting Adsense off sites which tend to opt for far more in-your-face and dubious ad networks anyway.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by pdeuchler on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:31PM (#12954638)
That's not bias, it's just over fitting the model
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by jakewins on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:44PM (#12954715)
I hear this often from engineering friends - if you cannot be unbiased, the problem is unsolvable. This gets applied to things like moral dilemmas in law or, like you do here, to news reporting.

Meanwhile, the actual professions of journalism and law have hundreds of years of thought put into how to approach this problem. The courts navigate and make judgement calls every day on provably subjective topics. There's a reason the first thing they teach you in J-school is that there's no such thing as "unbiased".

Hence, I entirely disagree with you, and instead think it's awful that we've allowed the nations largest media institution to pretend to be an "unbiased platform" for this long.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by ebola1717 on Monday November 14, 2016 @08:08PM (#12954815)
Plus, tech makes gray decisions like this all the time. Youtube's Content ID system, for example. Or any porn/spam classifier.
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by treebog on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:34PM (#12954659)
They're not taking a stand on which news stories are true and which are false. They're targeting sites that exist only to spread false information and make no attempt to be truthful in any story. These aren't news sites that occasionally write sketchy stories. These sites generate exclusively fake "news" content and fraudulently try to pass it off as the real thing.

Maybe someday we'll reach the slippery slope, and it will be harder to tell the real news sites from the fake ones. But at the moment, there are certain sites around the net that are obvious frauds, and it is good that Google is taking steps to reduce their influence.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by jwtadvice on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:54PM (#12954757)
So... every media outlet?

Are we talking about infowars here? Zero Hedge? The Occupy Wall Street blog? RT and SANA? The National Enquirer? Or are we talking about The Onion?

Do you think that Google will withdraw ads from sites that have partisan takes on news? Do you think that Google with withdraw ads from sites that pull their information from foreign narrative?

Google is an information monopoly that partners with the US military. It already skews its information to the benefit of the United States, where it can. It has every right to do this, as it is a private organization. But this does illustrate the danger of abuse of monopoly power.

Without real insight into the operation Google has yet again passed extremely dangerous authoritarian policies without any transparency.

To that question: can you please give examples of what you think they are going to decide count as fake news websites? Please share a few links. Presumably there are so many this is a such a huge problem it needs Google to attempt to defund it.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by treebog on Monday November 14, 2016 @08:57PM (#12955025)
Some sites which are contain nothing but blatantly false fake news: christ wire dot org daily currant dot com (claims to be a "parody" site, but does not attempt to be funny)

If you use facebook, you have probably seen these and similar sites pop up, shared by people who think they reflect real news. They exist to confuse people and score clicks in the confusion.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by jwtadvice on Monday November 14, 2016 @09:23PM (#12955129)
The parody site from this article?: http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2010/09/christwire.html

It absolutely is parody.

I regret using Facebook for many reasons. Really poorly informed politicking and sharing of tabloids unfortunately hasn't been invented or exacerbated by Facebook.

The most onerous and pernicious trading of misinformation I've seen on Facebook has been impressions originating from 'credible' sources: that Putin and Trump are best friends (Hillary Clinton and the DNC), that Saddam Hussein had some connection to 9/11 and also had nuclear weapons (George Bush, the White House Press Secretary and the US mainstream media), that there is no global assassination program, deal with Iran, that the US coalition wasn't supporting ISIS (the Obama Administration), Clinton had a 100% chance of winning this election (every reputable news source), that the South China Sea is about Chinese "aggression" (Obama Administration), there was nothing illegal and nothing interesting in Secretary of State emails and similarly in the DNC leaks (State Department and Clinton Campaign), there was no mass surveillance even indicated by the Snowden Documents (effectively all mainstream American media), the (first) fake US invasion of Fallujah (US military and New York Times), that nothing was happening in Ferguson after the State of Emergency (Federal Aviation), that China's economy was about to fall instead of giving the real news about their entering the special economic basket (HBR, The Economist, BBG + NPR), fake news about the assassination of Qaddafi [and his rape, and the US involvement in continued intentional regime change] (CNN, mainstream news reporting), the whitewashing of the genocide in Bahrain (CNN international), etc.

In higher level education in the United States, they tell history studies students to completely forget everything from their K-12 education, and they start over.

The reason for this is that K-12 history education looks nothing like actual recorded history, and is subject to the need for the state to educate a positive portrait of itself in order to build support among its population base.

The problem with this pernicious bubble of mis- and dis-information affecting even high levels of otherwise erudite conversation is that because it's trusted-by-default source, questioning it (as it is actually prudent to do) is considered 'disruptive' and 'irresponsible' while assuming and parroting establishment narrative as somehow factual, unstrategic or unbiased is considered 'polite' while it at the same time justifies enormous human cost and tragedy.

This pernicious bubble is a much larger problem than silly National Inquirer articles, as it has much greater negative effects and is much, much more populous.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by inopinatus on Monday November 14, 2016 @08:02PM (#12954797)
Just want to point out that that definition could reasonably be said to include The Onion. Being a parody site indicates intent to amuse of course, rather than to misinform. But discerning intent programmatically may be even harder than identifying truth.
Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by jrnichols on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:38PM (#12960867)
I'm seeing more websites (that are loaded with ads from different ad networks) posting older legitimate news stories, but as if they were new breaking news stories.

I worry that'll be harder to curb.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by tptacek on Monday November 14, 2016 @08:20PM (#12954862)
These are spam sites. They're automatically generated, sometimes even using spun text from stories from other spam sites. They are populated with nonsense: one which a friend unwittingly shared with me on Facebook had in its archives:

* A story that the Pope had endorsed Trump

* A story that the Pope had praised Russia's handling of the Ukraine

* A story that the Pope was involved in demonic blood sacrifice rituals.

(always look at the archives! They're great!)

The only thing that makes them interesting is that their goal isn't necessarily to generate money. Presumably, Google will just apply the same approaches it uses to detecting remunerative webspace to political webspam.

I don't like The Daily Caller or Breitbart, but there is no confusing fakenews sites with real ones. I don't think the suggestion here is that Google is going to audit stories on Breitbart.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by DominikR on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:41PM (#12954689)
Sorry, but I never got the news that it is now considered a good idea in our Western societies to censor information you do not like for political reasons.

I'm probably a racist homophobe bigot for writing these words and should be put in a correction camp, sorry.

Re:Google updating policy for ads on fake news sites by myowncrapulence on Monday November 14, 2016 @07:52PM (#12954754)
Surely Trump will make our media and government more transparent. That'll show those on the other side of the dichotomy! Now let's start making generalizations about them too!