News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Review: Touch Bar MacBook Pros give an expensive glimpse ... by dpark on Monday November 14, 2016 @04:11PM (#12953402)
> There are many reasons this is true, but the biggest one for me is that your finger obscures things on the display when you use it, and there is often very poor or no tactile feedback.

This is a poor argument against touch interfaces on laptops/desktops. This argument applies 100% to every touch interface, and yet we use touch interfaces for phones, and tablets, and modern point-of-sale systems, and the decent car navigation systems, etc, etc.

There are compelling arguments against touchscreens on laptops and desktops, but this doesn't seem to be one.

Re:Review: Touch Bar MacBook Pros give an expensive glimpse ... by khedoros1 on Monday November 14, 2016 @06:51PM (#12954421)
Tactile feedback isn't a compelling argument against touchscreens on laptops and desktops?

The touch interface on my phone and tablet compromises some of the usability of the input to gain a ton of flexibility and portability. Laptops compromise some comfort and size to make it feasible to stick a keyboard and pointer device into a thin, portable computer.

The various compromises are worth it in some situations and very out-of-place in others. I don't really see the point of a touch interface for general desktop/laptop use.

Re:Review: Touch Bar MacBook Pros give an expensive glimpse ... by dpark on Monday November 14, 2016 @08:14PM (#12954841)
No, I don't think "lack of tactile feedback" is, by itself, sufficient to demonstrate that touchscreens are a bad idea for laptops. There's nothing I can see about laptops that make the lack of tactile feedback a bigger concern than it is for other devices.

Lack of tactile feedback might be a bigger problem on laptops, but the reason it's a bigger problem is not self evident.

Re:Review: Touch Bar MacBook Pros give an expensive glimpse ... by khedoros1 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @02:17AM (#12956239)
> here's nothing I can see about laptops that make the lack of tactile feedback a bigger concern than it is for other devices.

Agreed, there's nothing about it that makes it a bigger concern for a laptop than other devices. Touchscreens as inputs are suboptimal on other devices too. They're uncomfortable, slow, and imprecise.

I'm a huge fan of physical buttons. Sadly, it's impractical to have a phone with a screen large enough to be useful, thin enough to fit nicely in a pocket, and have it equipped with decent input.