Re:Maine Ranked Choice Voting Initiative Approved
by tehwalrus on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:34PM
(#12952084)
Instant runoff matches four of the postulates, including all three that FPTP matches. It is a superset of the fairness of the other, they are not "equally unfair in different ways" or anything like that.
Re:Maine Ranked Choice Voting Initiative Approved
by tehwalrus on Monday November 14, 2016 @04:41PM
(#12953618)
Edit time threshold passed so I'll have to reply to myself.
I've just read up on Arrow, and this theory only has four postulates not five: I'm pretty sure I've either misremembered or am talking about a different theory. Apologies, anyway.
You're replacing one flawed system with another flawed system, so you should not argue in terms of the presence or absence of flaws, but rather argue why one is better than the other.
RCV can still have outcomes that a majority will disagree with, but it should be less common than FPTP, and also make third parties competitive in practise. That may be better than the old system (and it also may not be), but it's not going to resolve the fundamental tensions of representative democracy.