News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diamonds Suck (2006) by ryandrake on Sunday November 13, 2016 @06:06PM (#12946285)
> So if she insist, don't be angry at her - be angry at De Beers.

By doing so, you're ignoring her agency and her role in the problem. It's not like DeBeers has some kind of mind control laser pointed at the brains of every woman in the world. They put out advertising, and some people fall for it.

If you need to be angry about something, be angry about our education system which fails to teach people to think critically about what they see on their glowing god-screens.

Re:Diamonds Suck (2006) by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 13, 2016 @06:47PM (#12946489)
I didn't mean that De Beers is actually lasing neurons in womens' brains. But they shaped the culture around western wedding rituals by a century's worth of heavy marketing.

> If you need to be angry about something, be angry about our education system which fails to teach people to think critically about what they see on their glowing god-screens.

I would cut the education system some slack here. Advertising isn't a physical constant - it's a dynamic, optimized product of other humans. Smart humans who weaponize psychological and sociological research to maximize the impact of marketing techniques. An individual doesn't stand much of a chance against it by the very virtue of how professional specialization works. Even if people all suddenly became perfect critical thinkers, advertising industry would focus on exploiting some other weak spots.

> By doing so, you're ignoring her agency

A tangent, but I'm increasingly believing that individuals have much less agency than it is generally believed. We all strongly respond to incentives, especially in areas that strongly matter to our lives.

Re:Diamonds Suck (2006) by alexhawdon on Sunday November 13, 2016 @06:56PM (#12946528)
I'd agree with you if this were any other product. The marketing campaign in this instance was so utterly, totally, disastrously successful that it's become a cultural phenomena.

Really, you've got to hand it to them. And I have to agree it's not a fault to be sensitive to the judgement of your peers.

Re:Diamonds Suck (2006) by vacri on Sunday November 13, 2016 @08:25PM (#12946849)
It's still ignoring her responsibility if, when provided with the new information, she decides to ignore it.