News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by shmerl on Sunday November 13, 2016 @03:16AM (#12942395)
> just not copyleft licenses.

That's already a problem and discriminates against a major part of FOSS projects.

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by stephenr on Sunday November 13, 2016 @11:22AM (#12944032)
Isn't the problem that gpl(3?) is incompatible with the App Store rules?

Does apple actually forbid certain licences, or is this just another case of GPL fans assuming everyone else has to adapt to them?

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by shmerl on Sunday November 13, 2016 @12:01PM (#12944253)
GPLv3 protects the user against DRM. And if store forbids such licenses, then the store isn't FOSS friendly.
Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by stephenr on Sunday November 13, 2016 @12:10PM (#12944311)
What the gpl claims to do for Users or developers is irrelevant.

The question is why a developer can't publish gpl3 code to the App Store?

Is it because of an apple rule or is it because gpl3 says the developer can't do that?

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by icebraining on Sunday November 13, 2016 @01:22PM (#12944733)
The problem is that Apple imposes restrictions on the use of apps, even if the app developers themselves don't want to. For example, did you know you can't use your iPhone apps for non-personal, commercials purposes? That means that legally, if you use any app for "any fare, fee, rate, charge or other consideration, or directly or indirectly in connection with any business, or other undertaking intended for profit"[1], you're breaking the Store rules and can have your account terminated.

The GPL doesn't allow the users rights to be restricted in this way, hence the incompatibility.

[1] 18 U.S. Code § 31

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by stephenr on Sunday November 13, 2016 @09:36PM (#12947128)
> did you know you can't use your iPhone apps for non-personal, commercials purposes?

Can you point to the App Store rule that says this?

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by DanBC on Sunday November 13, 2016 @09:45PM (#12947166)
Here's what it says. I don't think it forbids commercial use. I'm not quite sure what it says.

http://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/itunes/us/terms...

> SERVICES AND CONTENT USAGE RULES

> Your use of the Services and Content must follow the rules set forth in this section (“Usage Rules”). Any other use of the Services and Content is a material breach of this Agreement. Apple may monitor your use of the Services and Content to ensure that you are following these Usage Rules.

> All Services:

> - You may use the Services and Content only for personal, noncommercial purposes (except as set forth in the App Store Content section below).

[...]

> App Store Content:

> - The term “App” includes apps, iMessage and Apple Watch apps, in-app purchases, extensions (such as keyboards), stickers, and subscriptions made available in an app.

> - You can use Apps on any device that you own or control.

> - Individuals acting on behalf of a commercial enterprise, governmental organization or educational institution (an “Enterprise”) may download and sync Apps for use by either (i) a single individual on one or more devices owned or controlled by an Enterprise; or (ii) multiple individuals on a single shared device owned or controlled by an Enterprise. For the sake of clarity, each device used serially or collectively by multiple users requires a separate license.

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by icebraining on Monday November 14, 2016 @02:03AM (#12948023)
Notice how the exception in the last clause only applies to "devices owned or controlled by an Enterprise". What I wrote is that using your iPhone is not allowed, and that's plain from the terms.
Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by stephenr on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:22PM (#12951418)
I'm pretty sure that rule is saying: you can install an App on multiple devices for one user, or one device for multiple users, but you're not supposed to install a single purchased app on a whole fleet of devices that will be used by multiple people.
Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by DanBC on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:45PM (#12951641)
But this rule is pretty clear, no? What am I missing?

> You may use the Services and Content only for personal, noncommercial purposes

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by stephenr on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:56PM (#12951732)
> What am I missing?

Um, this:

> (except as set forth in the App Store Content section below)

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by shmerl on Sunday November 13, 2016 @12:14PM (#12944335)
> What the gpl claims to do for Users or developers is irrelevant.

Indeed it isn't, we weren't even talking only about GPL. We were discussing that claims about Apple "opening up to FOSS" are bogus, until they'll fix the glaring examples of being hostile to FOSS, like above.

> Is it because of an apple rule or is it because gpl3 says the developer can't do that?

It's clearly caused by Apple's restriction on the store, since there is no problem releasing GPL software from many other stores and repositories.

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by stephenr on Sunday November 13, 2016 @09:39PM (#12947138)
It clearly must be a copyleft issue, since there is no problem releasing permissive licensed code on the App Store.

See what I did there?

Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by shmerl on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:53AM (#12947988)
Issue caused by Apple who ban copyleft from the store, yes. So, going back to the main point - they aren't friends of FOSS, far from it.
Re:Apple is doubling down on open source by stephenr on Monday November 14, 2016 @02:13AM (#12948054)
Well if you want to be a child and repeat your tired argument continuously, you do that.

Given that the article is specifically titled open source not "free software" I don't even see how your "point" came up.