Re:U.S. judge rejects World Chess bid to block websites from...
by riskable on Saturday November 12, 2016 @01:49PM
(#12939441)
I'm failing to see what's wrong with this. I also don't see how an organization like the NBA or FIFA or whoever can make a claim to "own" the events of a game.
The sale of exclusivity rights seems like the scam: The premise that one can copyright an event itself and not just a particular recording of it.
If someone is there and recording I say that should be OK. If another person aggregates the views of multiple such recorders then they would need to obtain permission from each.
Reconstructing the entirety of a game with virtual players is already legal and amounts to an original work. Where's the problem?
Re:U.S. judge rejects World Chess bid to block websites from...
by egeozcan on Saturday November 12, 2016 @07:26AM
(#12937564)
I'm not sure why this is down-voted. This what came to my mind first as well. I'm not a lawyer, so, maybe there is something fundamental that is wrong with the argument, but it would be nice if someone just explained instead of down-voting.
You have a soccer match in which a lot of fans show up with cameras. Either like a Go-Pro or just their phones, or like Google Glasses.
From the many fan cams, you can reconstruct the state of the match. From the FIFA video games, or from image analysis, you have all the player likenesses.
So then someone could "watch" the game from any vantage point, using just the "facts" of the game, without doing an actual re-broadcast of the game.
What then?