BUT. ACA as an independent portfolio selection agent only selected 55 of those. And only those 55 were used.
But since the first 123 were selected by Paulson we should ignore this fact.
Since we have already dismissed that ACA independently selected the portfolio, we shopuld also dismiss the fact that ACA's parent company invested $900 million in the CDO, because they believed in the validity of their choices.
But then again how is that in any way saying that they approved of the contents of the CDO.
Since we have established this,let me try and convince some law firms to start a class action against all colleges, universities, b-schools etc for giving students multiple choice questions, to try and influence their judgement that the answer can be something other than the right one.
Not exactly the same case as Paulson, ACA and Goldman, but its soooo close!
Paulson had a list of securities they wanted to short. ACA selected what was (in their opinion) the best set of long positions from this set. Goldman then sold a synthetic CDO based on the long positions. The exact positions were disclosed, in explicit detail, to every buyer.
This is how nearly every synthetic CDO is constructed.
So it's clear that ACA sucks. I've never argued that wasn't the case. But ACA's suckage in no way bears on the fact that Goldman plainly lied about the selection process to longside investors (who clearly suck, as well).
In summary: everyone involved sucks, except maybe Paulson. Goldman's the only party that criminally sucks, though, at least that we know of right now.
How does that not constitute fraud?