News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by revx on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:53PM (#12925902)
There's a difference between respecting someone's ideological preference, and discouraging hate speech. I like to think of it like this: your liberties to express ideology end where someone else's human rights begin.

I would disagree with firing someone for saying that they liked Trump. I would agree with firing someone for making racist, sexist, or otherwise derogatory comments toward a co-worker. I think that's what GrubHub's CEO is getting at.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by fdsaaf on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:02PM (#12925981)
> There's a difference between respecting someone's ideological preference, and discouraging hate speech

No there is not. "Hate speech" is what liberals call inconvenient conservative speech. Approving all speech except "hate speech" is just declaring that you will censor speech you find disagreeable.

The only legitimate speech restrictions are viewpoint-neutral no matter what the viewpoint.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by MaysonL on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:26PM (#12926176)
"You're a dirty monkey and should go back to Africa" is inconvenient conservative speech? You'll have a difficult time defending that statement.
Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by fdsaaf on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:37PM (#12926257)
That statement is absolutely protected speech.
Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by revx on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:23PM (#12926534)
I think you're mistaking the purpose of the 1st amendment. Racist comments are protected speech in that the United States Government cannot arrest/imprison/etc. you for that kind of speech.

Freedom of speech does not mean freedom of repercussions for your speech. New York is an at-will state, meaning there is no legal problem with this email. There is no protection for people getting fired for hate speech, just like there is no legal protection for people boycotting or refusing to work for companies that they disagree with.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by fdsaaf on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:04PM (#12926788)
Private enterprises aren't required by law to uphold a high standard of free speech, but being decent Americans does. The government MUST NOT censor, but private companies SHOULD NOT.
Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by revx on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:19PM (#12926867)
I think we have a very different standard of what a "decent American" is. Perhaps we'll have to agree to disagree for now.
Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by masondixon on Sunday November 13, 2016 @01:08PM (#12944627)
What if a black person said this to another black person?

My point is that "hate speech" is not clear cut.

Today, the left is using it to silence any opposition.

If someone says "hate speech" is writing "Trump" on the ground with chalk, where does it end?

How do you draw the line?

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by revx on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:55AM (#12958458)
I think I was pretty clear about where I draw the line.

> your liberties to express ideology end where someone else's human rights begin.

I won't respect your opinion if it disrespects someone's existence.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by generic_user on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:32PM (#12926221)
We are discussing these terms in a specific context of this email. Wild straw men arguments do not contribute to the discussion. Unless you can find someone saying,

> You're a dirty monkey and should go back to Africa

I would refrain from such bombast.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by yequalsx on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:11PM (#12926054)
I think it would be best to delete your second sentence. Let's not delve too deeply into group A vs. group B. Your comment would be much better without it.

You are right that hate speech is a charge that can get blown out of proportion. The question then becomes how to define it in a way that protects ideological differences.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by generic_user on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:26PM (#12926170)
> If you do not agree with this statement then please reply to this email with your resignation because you have no place here.

That is clearly stating that if you have an ideological disagreement hand in your resignation. Contradicting the claim he supports 'ideological inclusion and tolerance' in the preceding paragraph.

Nowhere in the text does the term 'hate speech' come up. He does make a reference to demeaning behaviour. That could easily mean ideological disagreement. If you find someones views on H1B visas demeaning they should hand in there resignation.

Also he states,

> we do not tolerate hateful attitudes on our team.

Again he states there is no tolerance for attitudes he may disagree with. Attitudes are simply ideas informed by ideology. What constitutes a hateful attitude could be any political disagreement of principle. Including voting for Trump.

This seems like a fairly pointed address to Trump voters that they should hand in there resignation.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by inimino on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:51PM (#12926713)
It's confused. The paragraph previous to that is talking about protecting people from discrimination. If you read it charitably there's a perfectly reasonable interpretation.

Of course, a CEO should write defensively even against uncharitable interpretation and this is a pretty spectacular failure on that level.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by generic_user on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:16PM (#12926849)
It reads like an emotion charged poorly proofread diary entry that could at some point be used as material for a company wide email.

The fact that he just sent that out like it is on an impulse hints that there is a whole lot of reflective internal composure and professionalism filters that are missing. Thats not what you want to see in a CEO.

The language is ambiguous and buzz wordy enough that angry Clinton supporters could take it as a call to purge there fellow colleagues. And likewise Trump supporters could see it as a call for them to resign.

Overall, the damage this is going to do is precisely why you do not mix your personal politics and your business.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by smsm42 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @06:55PM (#12963446)
This also reads as reflex virtue signaling based on being sure that everybody in the company shares the same ideology bubble as the author, because all decent people do. This is only too frequent occurrence. No nuance was considered because none was necessary to consider - since everybody (worth considering) agrees anyway.
Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by inimino on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:22PM (#12926888)
Exactly.
Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by smsm42 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @06:51PM (#12963419)
He was talking not only about "hate speech" (though even this category has long since have been extended by some to include anything disagreeing with the Party Line) but about nationalism and policies of Trump in general, which has been wholesale called "hateful".

Of course, one can read it as "I oppose the policies of Trump that I consider hateful but not ones that are not" but since no way of distinguishing between the two has been offered, I assume that was not the intent and surely not how most of the people read it. It reads as a wholesale denunciation of Trump and his supporters as hateful. Maybe it wasn't the intent, but in that case the nuance was lost somewhere on the way.

In a message that instructs anybody who disagrees to resign the lack of nuance is not the best idea - unless that is exactly what the author meant.

Re:Grubhub CEO tells pro-Trump employees to resign by tn13 on Friday November 11, 2016 @02:03AM (#12928607)
There is no such thing as hate-speech. Hate Speech is free speech too. Other than a credible threat every other expression is free speech. It is a fundamental right for all Americans to use homophobic, racist, sexist speech if they want to.

It is also Grubhub CEO's right to fire anyone who he dislikes but then it cuts both ways. All conservatives must now abandon Grubhub.

With 50% of population disliking Grubhub I bet CEO will lose his job in a day for being an as*hole.