News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by ComteDeLaFere on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:09AM (#12920027)
Not sure why this is controversial. Boilers have an on/off switch, and when your company manages a large number of buildings, you automate and centralize on/off for efficiency's sake, no?
Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by mrweasel on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:19AM (#12920082)
That fair enough, but in this case the heating system is directly attached to the internet. The correct way of designing something like this is having the heating system as one system and the management system as another.

The management system can then receive information and MAYBE control some aspects of the heating system. If you remove or crash the management system, the heating system just reverts back to being a "dumb" heating system.

My question is: Why in the name of all that is holy does the heating system stop working just because the remote management interface decides to reboot?

This has to be design by the same idiots that believe that an in car infotainment system should be hooked up to the drive computer in a Jeep.

Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by digi_owl on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:08PM (#12922137)
a combo of cost cutting and safety requirements?
Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by robryk on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:26PM (#12922312)
What kind of incident could safety regulations be trying to prevent by forbidding a furnace from operating when remote control is unreachable?
Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by lisivka on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:47PM (#12923580)
Blow of tank, fire.
Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by robryk on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:22PM (#12924494)
There are other methods to prevent such occurrences: furnaces have "flame out of bounds" sensors and/or chimney flow sensors: this is very good at preventing the furnace from starting a fire of its own.

If there's already a fire present, whether furnace decides to stop operating or not is usually irrelevant (you can get a gas leak from a damaged furnace even if it's off). I do not see why _remote_ control should be able to prevent a fire from starting: whatever is remotely controlling this furnace doesn't have more data than the furnace itself.

Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by lisivka on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:30PM (#12924579)
So, circumvent your furnace control logic to burn at max rate when it receives no commands from it remote controller, then go somewhere for a week. Engineers are stupid people, you know.
Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by robryk on Friday November 18, 2016 @04:59PM (#12990435)
My family has a furnace for heating water and the house. The furnace has a control unit that controls the burner and pumps. There is also a "manual operation" switch, to be used if the control unit fails, that simply switches everything on: pumps and the burner. The burner has a thermostatic control (that is set to a very high temperature and is essentially used to prevent it from boiling the water).

So, in this case, "burn at max rate" _is_ the safe setting to be used when the controller dies. The only unsafe situation that it will cause is that the hot utility water will be scaldingly hot, but there will be no increased danger of fire nor of CO poisoning.

Re:DDoS attack halts heating in Finland amidst winter by ohyes on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:18AM (#12920079)
No, you generally have a a control device on site. You probably also have some backup/safeguards in place in case the controller fails.

In essential systems you have to build for robustness over efficiency.