News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump, our next president, promised to block AT&T/Time Wa... by icebraining on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:18PM (#12916341)
If anything the people who invest in index funds are freeloaders

No. How much wealth could those individuals create if they couldn't sell the companies on the market and invest that money, and had instead to accumulate dividends? The relationship is symbiotic.

Yes, Trump created wealth, but the point is that his peers would have created even more if he hadn't used that money himself. To make an analogy, I can swim a few laps, but you wouldn't want to have me replace Michael Phelps on your team.

Re:Trump, our next president, promised to block AT&T/Time Wa... by pg314 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:21AM (#12918908)
Trump has created wealth, but he also destroyed wealth in his multiple bankruptcies and the contractors he stiffed. One could argue that casinos (even if they are profitable) are a net destructor of wealth. It is very hard to get a clear picture of exactly how much net wealth he created since there is no reliable information. Tax returns would have been a good start...

His father, Fred Trump, built a real estate empire of 27.000 apartments in Brooklyn and Queens. Just sitting on those and maintaining and expanding it would have resulted in a fortune many times bigger than he has today.

Re:Trump, our next president, promised to block AT&T/Time Wa... by tanderson92 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:26PM (#12916415)
I may have been a bit hyperbolic about freeloaders.

The bigger point I want to make is that the standard deviation on returns of a single venture like Trump's is so large that you cannot meaningfully compare it to a highly-diversified basket of stocks.

To use your analogy, it'd be like evaluating the effectiveness of a coach in a swimming event by picking a single one of their swimmers and comparing them to the average times of the U.S. Olympic team. Does this necessarily imply anything at all about the skill of the coach?

Re:Trump, our next president, promised to block AT&T/Time Wa... by zaphods-towel on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:19PM (#12917430)
I feel like you're making an argument against your thesis instead of for it (?). With higher risk, you expect higher return... so isn't that another tick against Trump's "success"? His ventures were way riskier than an index fund (see bankruptcies and losses), yet they had a markedly lower return. That means they were not good investments.
Re:Trump, our next president, promised to block AT&T/Time Wa... by tanderson92 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:26AM (#12918425)
Well there are two possibilities: 1) Trump's businesses are lower risk and so the lower realized return is as expected 2) there is significant idiosyncratic risk in a single company which can diversified away with the S&P500 while maintaining the same expected return.

I disbelieve (1) because of his multiple high-profile bankruptcies.

Re:Trump, our next president, promised to block AT&T/Time Wa... by asdfasdfa11112 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:38PM (#12916906)
It does not, but it is a useful benchmark to evaluate the claims of a swimmer with below average times who insists they become team captain.