News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by laserDinosaur on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:53AM (#12911884)
>The only job for me is in Seattle or Bellevue or Redmond, an hour-long commute

I don't mean to belittle your situation but..an hour seems like fantastic commuting time. Most people I work with take an hour to an hour and a half to get to work. Up until our office moved there was two guys that had a 2 hour trip into work every day. Most people I know would kill to have an hour commute.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by blakeyrat on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:10PM (#12912110)
Yeah, but... doesn't that suck for everybody? Commuting time is wasted. (Maybe on public transit, if it's not so crowded you can pull out a laptop, you can get a bit of work done.) It's American productivity going straight into the toilet.

But you're also kind of missing the point of my post, focusing on one small tree and forgetting there's a whole forest out there. Whether it's an hour, or an hour and a half, or 45 minutes isn't the point-- the point is we should optimizing it as close to zero as possible.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by kbenson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:05PM (#12912806)
> Yeah, but... doesn't that suck for everybody?

Yes.

> Commuting time is wasted.

Commuting time is a reserved time, which makes it less useful because it's inflexible, but it isn't necessarily wasted. I have quite a few podcasts I listen to, and there's some I'm interested in listening to more than all but the most interesting TV shows on. I have a short commute, just 20 minutes or so each way, and I only do it three times a week, but I find myself happy to run errands after work because it gives me more time when I can listen to the shows I want, as I'm at that point where they stack up faster than I can listen to them, and that's with me aggressively culling the ones I never seem to get to because there are so many I like slightly more so I never have time for them.

Commuting can be a wasted time or you can try to use it for what it is, a block of time where you have limited options, and try to make the best of those options.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by thebspatrol on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:41PM (#12913868)
Oh yeah, I love commuting listening to music and livestreams, but you can't assume everyone does.

Public transit shouldn't be reserved for major east-coast cities and for poor people.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by kbenson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:58PM (#12914036)
> Oh yeah, I love commuting listening to music and livestreams, but you can't assume everyone does.

I agree, but that's not all there is. There are audio books, serialized fiction, narrated short stories in every medium you can think of, extended learning, and I'm sure more I can't think of. Finding something to do in this time is less a problem of content and more a problem of knowing it exists.

It of course doesn't negate that it does take time away you could choose to do something else, but it can make the time less onerous.

> Public transit shouldn't be reserved for major east-coast cities and for poor people.

Public transit doesn't change the equation all that much though. It means you need to be less actively involved in the process, so there's more available to you (visual mediums), but it's still time that is reserved for commuting. You aren't physically playing with your children during that time, or visiting with family.

Quick access routes to economic hubs might easy associated problems somewhat (double digit percentages if you're lucky), but it doesn't actually change the equation that is at play here, which is that dense groups of people have many benefits, and living close to that is desirable, and we all know what happens when demand outstrips supply.

The biggest gains you'll probably ever see in this area are likely to be had by putting less restrictions on an entirely different dimension of travel. Group your population up, not just out.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Grishnakh on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:16PM (#12915270)
If we want to stop wasting so much valuable time commuting, we need to be building the SkyTran system.

There's natural network effects to people congregating in larger cities rather than small towns (at least towns too far from cities to commute). There's a reason most industry is located in cities. Instead of trying to fight these natural effects, you need to concentrate on using technology to counter the downsides.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:09PM (#12912095)
What are people putting up with such crazy commutes? Where do you live?

Why don't people just move closer, or change jobs?

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by blakeyrat on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:11PM (#12912125)
You obviously don't live in the Seattle area. You can't move closer, because real estate is literally twice as expensive as where you currently live, and you can't change jobs because all the jobs are in the same places with the crummy commutes. About the only factor you can optimize is picking jobs that are along mass transit routes.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:41PM (#12912519)
I am living and working in Central London. Thank you.

Why can't you move? If real estate is twice as expensive, just pick a place half the size?

Don't you value your own time---wasted in commuting---at any positive dollar figure at all? If you spend an hour commuting each way for 21 days a month, that's 52 hours a month extra that you spend on `work', even if your employer doesn't gain anything from it.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by antisthenes on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:24PM (#12913078)
Because, for whatever reason, he likes owning a house.

Which is doublespeak for him feeling entitled to live in a huge and inefficient property for no reason other than him liking it.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by vecinu on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:10PM (#12913512)
I think there are a couple of forces at work here that aren't clear cut.

Perhaps there are families out there that need more space, would like to be self-sufficient especially in emergency situations and feel happier outside of an urban center.

I think if we build these types of communities/houses, we should have a way of sustaining them. This man wants to work and is not asking for a handout. This should be celebrated and the person should be given work to do to earn his keep.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:23PM (#12934483)
It would be nice, if that person can find work. But I don't know what you mean by `should be given work'. I don't think we should force anyone to employ them.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by gph on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:02PM (#12913452)
That's not really doublespeak. And it doesn't have to be less efficient to own a house. Can't put solar panels on my apartment roof. Can't plant much of a garden to localize some of my consumption.

If you were really eco-conscious you could probably get more gains out of owning your own house. Especially since most houses have already been built, whereas most of the new construction I see in my city (Baltimore) is going towards mixed-use condos/apartment towers for all the trendy folks wanting to live downtown. If they really cared about the environment and efficiency they'd be fixing-up the thousands of run-down homes.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by SilasX on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:21PM (#12913643)
>Can't put solar panels on my apartment roof.

That's pretty small relative to the extra energy consumption from having to commute farther, and the land that you might live on could be used for solar power regardless of whether you live there.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by gph on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:31PM (#12913754)
Guess I was thinking more of my situation than the OP's in Seattle. I can commute downtown Baltimore in about 30 mins (~8 miles) from my suburban house. Leaf does it on a single charge. Guess I would have to do the math, but I'd think the drop in electricity consumption, especially in the summer heat, is enough to offset my commute.

It's definitely not typical since I'm in the minority of solar panel and electric car owners who are within commute range on a single charge. But there you have it. It's at least possible.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by SilasX on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:41PM (#12913863)
The subthread OP (antisthenes) was referring to the global (system level) inefficiency of large-home far-out living, not the inefficiency for a household's budget (which is distorted by policy).

For purposes of that calculation, it's double-counting to include the solar panel energy, because we can already put a solar panel at that location regardless of whether you live and commute from there; your choice to live there did not expand our solar energy capability, and you're still avoidably drawing down the supply of clean energy.

Just to clarify: I'm not criticizing your decision, only justifying why it's not an argument against this being a systemic inefficiency.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by gph on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:09PM (#12914134)
Sure, but I guess my point was that systematically we aren't building solar panels and creating the greatest possible efficiency of the overall system. You're kind of describing an ideal efficient system where we coordinated together perfectly. But that's not really how we as humans or a society work. If I moved out of my house into an apartment it's unlikely anyone will put up extra solar panels to offset the loss. My consumption would fall back onto the norm of the grid, which is mostly fossil fuels. But as an individual I can make choices which will create the greatest net efficiency.

But I guess I'm really getting into the definition of efficiency. I suppose in my mind I'm considering clean energy as more efficient even though from an economic POV fossil fuels are still more efficient based on price (though probably not for long).

So in conclusion, you're right. I'd just add the caveat that faced with the reality of a mostly uncoordinated system run by large groups of people with competing interests, you can possibly find higher efficiency (depending on how you look at it) from making your own intelligent individual decisions while living in a large home away from the city center.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by SilasX on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:20PM (#12914231)
I wasn't referring to price efficiency, but the general efficiency of the system's use of resources. And I agree that given the house, you are improving that efficiency by adding the solar panel. The point was, the system had to significantly distort the resource scarcity signals to make it look appealing to build the house to begin with, and adding some solar energy doesn't change that calculus.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by gph on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:57PM (#12914573)
But most the houses are already built. I live in a house that was built in the 30s. So in my mind the resource cost has already been sunk into homes across the country. Instead a lot of folks are moving into new developments being built in downtown areas.

Perhaps repairing the houses would be less efficient than building new apartment blocks, I'm really getting well beyond my knowledge or expertise. But I'd somewhat presume that instead of building new high rise apartments downtown it would be more efficient overall if we refurbished some of the crumbling residential areas.

Course that only applies to older cities mostly on the East Coast.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:27PM (#12934529)
Building houses is relatively cheap. The housing stock on top of the land isn't what's so expensive in cities. It's the land underneath.

The cost of the housing stock is of minor importance in these arguments, and nobody suggest tearing down existing houses just for the sake of efficiency. That wouldn't make any sense.

(A house build and paid for once can stand for hundred years or more, but only with a constant expense on maintenance in either money or sweat.)

What we want is denser urban cores. That way there will be less sprawl, and even the country pumpkins would have shorter commutes, because the countryside could start so much closer to the city centres: given the same or even larger number of people in them cities, they would take up less space.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by stcredzero on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:01PM (#12914060)
Guess I would have to do the math, but I'd think the drop in electricity consumption, especially in the summer heat, is enough to offset my commute.

Fully charging the Leaf should be about the same as my Fiat 500e, and that's roughly equivalent to running a space heater for 18 hours. I'd conservatively estimate your commute takes 1/8th to 1/4th that power. (There are lots of details I don't know that could affect that.) It is roughly the same going by that.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by jsight on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:09PM (#12914676)
Yeah, it is pretty easy to offset that with a solar panel. On a sunny day, it would probably only take about 4 panels to do it for such a small commute.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Slaul on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:00PM (#12913432)
How is it wrong for him to want to live in a house because he likes it?
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by AdrianB1 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:02PM (#12914624)
He is not. He is wrong when he wants the government to force companies to bring jobs to his front door ("influencing companies", if you like smooth talk). It is his choice to live in a good place OR next to a good job. It is not government's problem in any case.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:51PM (#12914501)
Well, it's doublespeak for not wanting to actually trade-off personal lifestyle factors. Of course, nobody ever wants to do that, but we generally regard it as a Mature Adult Thing to do it anyway.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:15PM (#12915823)
That's fair enough, but then they shouldn't complain about their choice.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Splines on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:33PM (#12914341)
Those 52 hours of "work" can buy you a home, neighborhood and school district your children, spouse, (and you) enjoy living in. Whether or not those 52 hours are worth it is up to each family.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:32PM (#12922376)
Yes. Though you could also use those 52 hours to actually spend time with that spouse and children.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Grishnakh on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:18PM (#12915283)
Maybe because you can't raise kids in a one-room efficiency?
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by micaksica on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:29PM (#12916439)
This is false. Go to NYC and you'll find some poor children that did, in fact, grow up in one-room efficiencies, or lower-middle-class families in Tokyo. Their houses become places to sleep, and the entire city becomes the house most of the time otherwise. It is not common in America but it is certainly doable. Whether or not it is desirable to the children or the parents is a different story.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Grishnakh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:18AM (#12921037)
Well you can also raise kids in a single-room mud hut. That doesn't mean it's a desirable way to live in 2016.

Also, in most localities in the US, good luck getting custody of any kids if they don't have a separate bedroom.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:30PM (#12934559)
Alas, alone that commenter would not be able to change this.

On a policy level, we can make almost arbitrary amounts of rooms in cities: just build up.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Grishnakh on Sunday November 13, 2016 @06:41PM (#12946470)
That's the really annoying thing: there's no really good reason cities can't build more decent housing in high-rises. I suspect the problem is bad zoning laws and developers able to make more profit doing other things. Ideally, cities should be able to get developers to build lots of high-rises with moderately-priced condos and apartments, to pack more people in, which would also increase the efficiency of public transit. And these units should have a decent amount of space, by building up, so families can have a reasonable amount of living space. They just need to take action to clear out older, smaller buildings taking up valuable space (probably with punitive property taxes), and encourage development of high-rises (with property taxes which punish buildings that are too small).
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by brianwawok on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:06PM (#12913472)
Americans like their big houses. Silly
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by webXL on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:24PM (#12914272)
Yes, they're really quite nice and definitely wasteful, but we can't help it! It's policy: http://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/rethinkin...
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:28PM (#12934544)
Quite sad, especially when read in the light of "Why are there NIMBYs?" (https://www.dartmouth.edu/~wfischel/Papers/00-04.PDF)

In essence, the paper argues that highly-leveraged homeownership causes NIMBYs.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:32PM (#12912410)
Uh, I think you're being very dismissive here. There are many rational reasons for urban business.

Being able to get rental real estate for your business. In the suburbs you now need a loan, credit, collateral, 30% down, etc to build your own building as there generally isn't a rash of empty floors on skyscrapers like cities do.

Being able to have face to face meetings frequently with your investors, board members, and bankers and other people who hold your pursestrings.

Being able to find investors in the first place. Picture two similar business plans. One by a group in the far out suburbs and one nearby. As an investor, which one would you lean towards, especially if you expect yourself to do any hands on work or attend board meetings?

Being able to get to the airport and mass transportation hubs quickly.

Being able to wine and dine investors and customers in places that will impress them.

Being able to court youngsters and urban professionals who want a city life and won't even interview in the suburbs. (Hi! This is me and almost everyone I know.)

Being near urban universities for the above reasons and job fairs.

Being near your competitors to help you poach their staff.

Being able to work with a local government that understands business needs and not being subjected to a 'board of elders' of out of touch 70 year old suburban retirees who will bikeshed the shit out of any proposal of yours and NIMBY you to death.

Being able to quickly expand by taking more office space instead of, you guessed it, building another fucking building.

Being able to order 1gb fiber and have in here in 30 days as opposed to 360 days in the suburbs and that's on top of paying tens of thousands of dollars for that last mile to your office, which they will need to dig up just for you.

...and yes, maybe some perks of city life as you mention. Work life should have pleasant parts and it helps attract talent.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by SilasX on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:20PM (#12913628)
This is why I've suggested economic measuring well-being with the metric "discretionary income per hour lost to work" (DIPHLoW).

discretionary income: income minus taxes and base housing costs

hour lost to work: time at work plus time commuting or otherwise stuff you wouldn't otherwise have to do

That metric captures dynamics like "yeah there are jobs, but with much higher cost of living, so it cancels out the DIPHLoW" and "yeah you can live where it's cheaper but you have to commute an extra 90 minutes, which eliminates the impact on DIPHLow".

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:38PM (#12934641)
Thinking some more about, it would also make sense to look at some isotonic function of disposable income and disposable hours left (after work, commute, etc).

This is to capture that increasing working hours from 8h to 24h a day even when pay would be more than tripled, would leave you with a very sad life.

(Shadow) price of time would be a good one, too? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_price) In some sense, that's the same as marginal cost of your time, expressed in dollars or some `utils' or `hedons'.

Then you can say, eg taking a longer commute for a cheaper house would value my time at 30 hedons per hour---but spending time with my daughter is worth at least 50 hedons per hour. So it would be bad trade-off.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:33PM (#12922388)
That's a good concept. Can you come up with a sexier name?

(Or am I not getting a pun here?)

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by SilasX on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:54PM (#12922570)
Heh, that's the best I can come up with; just aimed for it being pronounceable (diff-flow). No pun intended, except maybe that it's the "difference" you keep that "flows" to stuff you can actually enjoy?

Edit: Also thought of "discretionary income per UnFree hour" (DIPUPH) ... not sexy either though.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by abledon on Friday November 11, 2016 @08:53AM (#12930584)
(DIPHLoW). sounds like Diplo, one of the most popular musical artists on the global top 50 (https://twitter.com/diplo).... so I think the abbreviation already 'fits' into popular cultures vocabulary of pronunciation, it just has to now tie in a new meaning to the word instead of 'Hugely Successful DJ'
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by hyperpape on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:02PM (#12912778)
Typical commute times are 30 or less. There are a few areas/jobs where that is not true, and it's a heavy cost for the people there.

I've read the above several places, but anecdotally, I live in Raleigh (technically Garner) commute 25-30 minutes to work, and have one of the longer commutes of people I work with.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by obj-g on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:04PM (#12912025)
Have to agree with you -- jeez, it used to take me 2 hours to get home and it was just from one side of Phoenix to the other using freeways. Currently, I live in Barcelona, and it takes me about 45 minutes when you add up walking to the metro, taking the metro, etc.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by cdelsolar on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:20PM (#12912253)
Yeah, it takes me about 1:15-1:20 each way, but most of it is on public transportation and I can get work done / play Pokemon / read / relax. I don't want to pay $4K a month to live in SF.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:39PM (#12912501)
Assuming you work 20 days a month, you are facing roughly 20 * 2 * 1.3 h = 52h of commute each way.

As a general yard stick of how you implicitely value your time:

$4k / 52h <= $77

Now, your current place probably costs money too, and your commute won't be cut to zero. You can plug in the numbers yourself:

($4k - current rent) / (52h - commute from apartment in SF) =: implicit value of one of your hours.

I hope you are making more than 77 dollar an hour as a programmer (?) in SF.

(Yes, I know, taxes complicate the picture. But only by at most a multiplier of 2.)

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by vecinu on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:12PM (#12913533)
I don't generally understand this train of thought. For employees that are full-time exempt (And most are), as long as you work a day, you are paid for 8 hours of work.

Whether your commute takes 3 hours or 3 minutes, you are paid the exact same because you can't work an extra hour instead of commuting for that $77.

Others folks that are on H-1Bs can't even work on side-hustles because of immigration law so what are they really missing out on?

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by SilasX on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:24PM (#12913675)
That's just a yardstick for how much it personally sucks (econ: "disutility") for you to go without that extra hour, estimated from your current pay. You could come up with a different value by deriving it a different way[1], but somehow you have to put a value on the time lost for purposes of comparison.

The existence of this opportunity cost doesn't require that you literally be able to put in an extra hour for extra pay.

[1] For example, you could go based on "how much would I pay for an extra hour to spend doing XYZ?"

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by madamelic on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:26PM (#12914280)
It doesn't even matter.

I do the same calculations simply to figure out if something is worth it.

For instance, laundry. I hate laundry. I could walk 100 steps to the laundromat, pay ~$5 to wash it. Or I could pay someone $15 to walk up to my door, take my laundry, wash it, fold it and return it to my door.

Ehhh... not that hard of a choice. The pain is worth $10.

I used to commute 1.5 hours every day and it was so incredibly painful, so I shopped around and found a cheap(-ish) place close to my work. My life is so much better now and I am much happier.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by eru on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:13PM (#12915807)
Exactly what the other commentators said.

Looking at your pay per hour is just a decent yardstick for when you should trade off time vs money. No need to find an outside job for the yardstick to be applicable.

Eg should you order groceries online, or go to the shop, or plant vegetables in your own garden? It's all a matter of time and money, and also hassle vs enjoyment---since some people dread going grocery shopping, and some people enjoy gardening.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by closeparen on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:10PM (#12914694)
It also takes me about an hour each way, and all of it is on public transit so I can't do anything except hold the overhead rail and try to keep balance or, on the rare occasion I get a seat, lean away from the laptop-using neighbor's elbow which is otherwise sitting in my lap.

As a subjective experience, crowded public transit and public transit with sufficient seating are entirely different things.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by irrational on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:48PM (#12912603)
Now you are making me feel bad for my 15 minute bike commute.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by m4x on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:23PM (#12912286)
So his point is even more relevant