News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by greenshackle2 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:49AM (#12911819)
Having the same opinion for 24 years is not a virtue.

In the (probably apocryphal) words of Keynes:

> When someone persuades me that I am wrong, I change my mind. What do you do?

It's not a sign of vice either; I'm sure he's been believing that the Earth is round for 24+ years, and that's fine. What matters is accuracy, and updating in the face of new evidence, not consistency. Consistency in the face of new evidence is called faith.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by ethanbond on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:53AM (#12911887)
His opinions were sound and his predictions were prescient. He was right. That's it. He was right about Iraq, he was right about financial deregulation, he was right about civil liberties.

Having the same opinion in and of itself is not a virtue, but having wisdom and foresight and conviction and true ground level initiative all at once is far more than just virtuous.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by conkrete on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:28PM (#12913721)
That may be true, but he's also a terrible role model that says extremely racist/sexist things. I couldn't quote president Trump at work without being fired from my job because of his lewd language.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by mintplant on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:53PM (#12913979)
This thread is discussing Sanders, not Trump.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by VLM on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:29PM (#12912367)
You're the only one repeatedly using the word "consistency" and then claiming that word is bad, which is kind of funny. That's because its a mistake you've made. That's OK. The correct word to use is "coherent". He's a believer in a complete and wide ranging logical philosophical system explaining the world resulting in a set of mutually compatible coherent opinions on all kinds of issues. That's why he's a statesman who's earned the respect of people even like me who disagree with him but can see a logical deeply reasoning fellow rational mind. And you try to compare that to someone who's idea of a philosophy, of the right systemic way to live a life, is to look at the polls, see X, Y, and Z are leading, well, guess I'm temporarily a supporter of X, Y, and Z. They're so dissimilar its almost impossible to compare the two.

You speak of faith and belief a lot. Bernie is like a wise theological scholar. Personally I think he's wrong about quite a few things, but I recognize the strong morals and ethics, the personal virtue, the deep rational thought, the coherent inter relatedness behind his system. He's a personification of sometimes wise people are wrong, but they still remain wise. He's not for me personally, I like other folks, but I'm proud he's an American and if he were the leader I could respect him despite disagreement. And his female opponent is like a televangelist seeking ratings and pledge drives, a faith healer, a fake messiah. And people somehow wonder how she lost. Doesn't her show have the highest ratings? Doesn't she make the best promises in her sermons? Don't our holiest people fall all over themselves to celebrate and show off their own holiness in supporting her? How could a charlatan like her not win, indeed?

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by greenshackle2 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:55PM (#12914007)
No, I meant consistency. You've misconstrued what I meant. That's ok. We all make mistakes sometimes.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by patmcc on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:02PM (#12911990)
>>Having the same opinion for 24 years is not a virtue.

It is if they were good opinions the whole damn time. Being for marriage equality for 24 years is a virtue. Being for an improved social safety net for 24 years is a virtue. Being for universal healthcare for 24 years is a virtue.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by sdegutis on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:43PM (#12912544)
Yep, the key about these is moral consistency. He was morally consistent the whole time, which shows integrity. Now, whether his positions were the right ones is another story...
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by dpc59 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:55PM (#12912686)
Vermont and Burlington are going pretty fucking good.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by bobjordan on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:57PM (#12912720)
Bernie's viewpoints were so far left that he had to hammer on them for 40+ years until the stars aligned and we all began to recognize the pearls of truth they held. Twenty years ago I could not have considered his viewpoint but now with more age and empathy driven into me I can get behind (most of) his viewpoint. Thank God for Bernie and hopefully we can rebirth a new democratic party that can integrate some of his views to help recapture a large part of the 59,000,000 people that felt compelled to vote for Trump.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by vidarh on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:20PM (#12913028)
This is what scares the Europeans amongst us about the US.

By European standards, most of the European centre-right is fine with most of what Bernie supports...

And then we wake up to Trump.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by sqeaky on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:07PM (#12913482)
As crazy as it might seem the USA has been right of center for a long (since WW2) and it is generally working well for us (we are so rich we don't even understand it). It is clearly not perfect (healthcare) but it does often work in unintuitive way (decade on decade carbon release decrease).

EDIT - Even though I think Trump is an existential threat to the USA, so have many of our leaders. Maybe 'us' wouldn't be the US if we weren't just a bit crazy. I must accept that I might be wrong about Trump be universally bad and see what happens.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by 1024core on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:30PM (#12912379)
> Having the same opinion for 24 years is not a virtue.

You are deliberately misinterpreting the statement. Of course having the same opinion for 24 years by itself is not a virtue! The point is: he has had the same public stance on things that matter : gay marriage, healthcare, etc. In today's climate, when politicians change their views based on the most recent polling, this is indeed a virtue.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by greenshackle2 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:52PM (#12913961)
> deliberately

How do you know that? Can you really not imagine that someone can misinterpret something without malicious intention?

Can you believe that I agree with OP that Bernie was the better candidate, yet still disagree about a particular argument?

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by blhack on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:26PM (#12912332)
>Having the same opinion for 24 years is not a virtue.

"I believe in universal human rights" is a virtue that I think it is perfectly acceptable to have to 24 years (or more!)

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by ep103 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:53AM (#12911882)
Its not a virtue for everyday people, its a virtue for politicians.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by findjashua on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:44PM (#12913279)
> Having the same opinion for 24 years is not a virtue.

That was not what GP was saying at all. He was saying that Bernie has always stood for what he believes is the right thing to do, whereas Hillary would pick a stance based on its political value.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by cmdrfred on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:53AM (#12911889)
Reconcile that with:

“But If Everybody's Watching, You Know, All Of The Back Room Discussions And The Deals, You Know, Then People Get A Little Nervous, To Say The Least. So, You Need Both A Public And A Private Position.”

https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/927

Her motives are clear.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by greenshackle2 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:07PM (#12912061)
I'm not commenting on the specifics of Berns and Hilary. I don't particularly like Hilary. I'm objecting to this type of argument in general.

Like, what if someone shows up and shows that Trump has had the same opinions all along? Is that a positive for him?

If the ideas are shitty, it doesn't matter how consistent or inconsistent they are. If they're good, I don't care if the person only adopted them 3 years ago, as long as they did for the right reasons, (e.g. not political expediency, I agree.)

I agree that the fact that he's held the same opinions for a long time is evidence that Berns doesn't act out of political expediency, but to me that point is far overshadowed by whether the ideas are any good.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Nadya on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:12PM (#12912127)
If someone holds a private and public"shitty" opinion and another holds a public opinion as a demagogue and privately holds the same "shitty" opinions, who would you rather? The one open and honest with their opinions or the dishonest one who will lie and say anything to win the popular vote?

>but to me that point is far overshadowed by whether the ideas are any good

Mind telling me where his ideas are bad? Most of his beliefs are both long held, progressive, and in my opinion, largely agreeable.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by gthtjtkt on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:52AM (#12911860)
> Having the same opinion for 24 years is not a virtue.

But being right for 24 years is.

She adopted his ideas one by one and then tried to pretend they'd been hers all along. Unfortunately (for her), Democrats aren't that gullible. It was clear that she was only saying what voters wanted to hear, while Bernie truly believed everything he'd been saying for that past 25+ years.

Case in point: https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/2631

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by greenshackle2 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:00PM (#12911966)
Correct, but being right is orthogonal to consistency. If you are exposed to new evidence, and it points in a different direction than your prior belief, being right means changing your mind; if there is no new evidence, or the weight of new evidence points in the same direction, being right means keeping the same belief.

All I'm saying is, you can't tout keeping the same idea for years as an unqualified good thing, you have to look at the idea and history in detail, and show that it was a good idea all along.

(I'm not objecting to the object-level argument that Clinton does whatever is politically expedient, I'm objecting to the line of argument that it's good for a politician to hold an opinion for a long time, without also showing that the idea is good, and that it was good all along.)

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by gthtjtkt on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:18PM (#12912226)
> you can't tout keeping the same idea for years as an unqualified good thing

You're missing the point completely.

I'm not praising Sanders' stubbornness, I'm praising his foresight and vastly superior judgment. He knew what this country needed to do 20 years before Hillary, and he was willing to vehemently defend his opinions despite the overwhelming opposition. The fact that you're trying to turn this into some kind of debate about consistency vs. facts is frankly baffling. It's clear that he was right all along and she was late to the party on every issue that liberals and progressives care about.

And do you really believe she changed her opinion on those issues where she claimed to have "evolved"? I sure don't. We know she still wants TPP to pass, we know she still secretly supports DOMA, we know she had no interest in reigning in Wall Street, we know she (and Chelsea) were halfheartedly pretending to support medical marijuana, etc. etc.. The Hillary Clinton presented to the public was a fictional character designed for one purpose: To win the presidency.

It didn't work, and the reason is clear: We're not as ignorant or gullible as they'd hoped: https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/3599#efmARhAWn

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by greenshackle2 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:54PM (#12912671)
> You're missing the point completely.

You're right, I got sidetracked by this:

> has been saying the exact same things for years

I keep forgetting not to try debating what is or isn't a good argument, in the abstract, in politics threads.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by croon on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:08PM (#12912845)
Well, it's because you're arguing what you did was somehow objectively relevant. That's a very binary stance.

What he said makes complete sense in the context he presented it in, and is valid.

You're arguing how what he said would be bad in an entirely different context, which is irrelevant.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by noobiemcfoob on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:07PM (#12912066)
> you can't tout keeping the same idea for years as an unqualified good thing

If that's the critique you hear when comparing Sanders to Clinton, you're not listening very well.

To restate, Sanders didn't just tout the same idea. He's fought for the same core principles throughout his whole career, even when in the clear minority. Overtime, the rest of our culture came around to those ideas (bringing Clinton with it).

His virtue isn't his tenacity. It's his progressive thinking.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by greenshackle2 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:18PM (#12912212)
Maybe. I can accept that I am taking the OP too literally when they say that Berns has been saying

> the exact same thing

for years.

I'm not American, I havn't looked into Berns' history in details.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by darawk on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:08PM (#12912081)
I don't think the OP was criticizing her lack of consistency. (S)He was criticizing her lack of being on the right side of the issues the first time (in the way that Bernie has been on many issues). It's easy to switch sides when everyone does, and nobody should criticize someone for doing that. But to many people, greatness is being on the right side of the issue before everyone else, and convincing people of its rightness.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by uabstraction on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:17PM (#12912981)
To boil this down farther, We are looking for a leader, not a follower. Hillary is a follower.

She has demonstrated over her career that she will vote for whatever is popular, lean on "think of the children" issues, and only vote progressively to catch up with the times. In a time where Congressional approval is so low, the American people couldn't stomach electing the epitome of a career politician who seems to have so many skeletons in her closet the door is about to burst (real or imaginary, the impression is there).

We ended up with Trump, which I am absolutely not thrilled about, but at least this will send the Democrats back to the drawing board to come up with something better than "Less Evil." I just pray to the FSM that the Republican House, Senate, Cabinet, and Supreme Court don't turn our great nation into a chop shop in the next 2 / 4 years. We are in for a bumpy ride.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by edko on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:26PM (#12912326)
I think you need both. You need the uncompromising Bernies, to act as visionaries and point out what the future should be. And, you also need the unprincipled politicians who can compromise, and adapt, and win elections. If Bernie had run in all previous elections, you would have probably gotten presidents Dole, McCain, and Romney. And, who knows, maybe Trump too.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by sqeaky on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:00PM (#12913435)
I am not convinced those presidents would have been bad. Can we say that they were all acting in the same way as "unprincipled politicians who can compromise, and adapt, and win elections" or maybe did they believe something earnestly that is just different from what you believe?

Would you rather have an ethically malleable liberal than a principled conservative? In most cases I would rather have the principled politician because they will have some kind of goal to benefit some segment of Americans. Can we really say that any ethically malleable politician, of any flavor, will always help some segment of Americans?

Then as a counter to all this. Nixon did found the EPA.

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by edko on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:21PM (#12913641)
I agree that maybe those presidents would not have been necessarily bad. Maybe, if Dole would have won, G.W. Bush would have never been elected, and the world would now be a very different (and better) place.

I think malleable politicians are malleable because they try to benefit the largest section of the population that they can. Conservatives, lately, have focused on benefiting a very small segment of the population directly, expecting the benefits to trickle down.

However, the trickle down has not worked. I know very little about economics, but, I remember, headlines in newspapers eight years ago were mainly about unemployment, and the growth of the National debt. The euro was $1.30 (now it buoys around $1.10).

I think the American economy is much better now than it was eight years ago, and a larger section of the population has benefited from that, than when principled conservatives were in the government. (And this is just from an economic point of view, which is a small part of the benefits).

Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by darawk on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:11PM (#12915786)
Ya don't get me wrong. I wouldn't totally castigate her for that. I was just trying to explain the criticism. You definitely need both kinds of people for different things at different times.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by Fargren on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:08PM (#12912076)
But consistently having to change your position is not a good sign. It's good to be able to change your mind. But it's hard to trust someone who changes a lot of their positions.
Re:Donald Trump Is Elected President by ahussain on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:08PM (#12912083)
No, but in this case he was right and consistent. She was eventually right and not consistent.