Re:Huffington Post's criticism of 538's election forecast
by rz2k on Monday November 07, 2016 @04:51PM
(#12895518)
Ther are cynical observations to be made about kurtosis and professional incentive structures for analysts and economists employed by investment firms.
However if his model performs with the precision of last time then the confidence intervals might be criticized as too wide.
This line of reasoning irks me -- If the outputs don't agree with with my preconceived conclusions, the model must be wrong. (Rather than: Maybe my preconceived conclusions are wrong.)
I don't have an opinion on the 538 model, not having analyzed the internals. But I don't like the idea of criticizing a model because you don't agree with its results.
On the bright side, the election will shortly be over and we'll have at least some measure of how accurate each model (538, HuffPo, etc.) actually was.