Re:Python's Original Sin
by kevindication on Friday April 23, 2010 @03:54PM
(#1289292)
He's likely arguing against any non-Functional Language. "Purely functional" Lisp has no statements, side-effects, etc, for instance.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
No, he's probably arguing in favor of expressions (i.e. stuff that returns values). Smalltalk has expressions everywhere, with control blocks being just closures passed to methods on objects ...
a < b
ifTrue: [^'A is less than B']
ifFalse: [^'A is greater or equal to B']
> "Purely functional" Lisp has no statements, side-effects, etc, for instance.Such a Lisp also has no users.
And no implementations.
Incorrect: ACL2, an industry-standard automated theorem-prover, is written in a side-effect-free variant of Common Lisp. It has both an implementation and users, including users outside of academia.
I guess both (no implementations, no users) were meant in relative terms, and in that light they describe reality pretty well.
Hands up, who has heard of ACL2 before?
I did.
In fact, I am appalled so few people, apparently, heard of it.
Any programming language that can't be cut-n-pasted from fifty different websites to make my SQL-injection-rich AJAX social awesome NoSQL site just isn't worth knowing. Theorem proving -- you ain't gonna need it!
What's next, you're going to tell me you write unit tests? Hahahahah.
In theory, at least, I wouldn't need them for I proof the program is correct ;-)