News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Which Microcontroller is Your favorite? by cnvogel on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:51PM (#1289134)
I've used Atmel AVR Classic, Mega and Tiny for quite a few projects using the gnu toolchain. The free compiler is quite good and programming cables can be made very cheap. To get more programming or debugging features you need a decent one though (DebugWire, high-voltage serial/parallel programming...). There's a windows distribution (winavr) that integrates well with the Atmel-provided AVR studio (but I never use that). They are fairly popular with the Arduino crowd that created their own variation of C which goes well with their own IDE. Internal functions are good (counters, sync/async serial ports, ADCs,...) but there are not many (e.g. only very few parts have two hardware async serial ports).

I've not used PICs, but they are said to have a bigger variety of parts that have different built-in functions. So you might find a better suited part in that family.

68HCxx and 8051 is very old-school, you can probably buy the "best tested" compilers and IDEs for those. This can be an advantage if you are working in/for a very antiquated industry. On the other hand, you can get astounding high speed-parts (I think it's silabs that makes 8051 MCUs >100 MHz)...

You forgot to mention the plethora of ARM-core MCUs which are made by several companies. Even if they come in many varieties, they are identical regarding tool-chain and programmer (they share the same JTAG logic). So this might be a good long-term investment. Also debugging via JTAG is very good. But being a 32bit architecture those MCUs are more often "high-end" parts (especially compared e.g. to 8-bit AVR tiny parts...). If you want a lot of computing power, that's possibly a good way to go.

Re:Poll: Which Microcontroller is Your favorite? by m_eiman on Friday April 23, 2010 @04:18PM (#1289358)
I left out the ARMs since they appear to be a bit on the expensive side (the ones I'm looking at cost about $4 in not so large quantities), and the ones I looked at didn't have much in the way of UARTs, ADC and IOs. I'll have another look though; I found some cheaper ones with a quick search on digikey.

As for the 8051 family, that's what I've been working with in the last two projects - and I'd like to find a better alternative. Both in terms of hardware (the number of page selectors needed to cram all those registers into 128/255 bytes of address space is just wrong) and software (I've used IAR and Keil, and neither feels like it's evolved too much since 2002).

Re:Poll: Which Microcontroller is Your favorite? by joezydeco on Friday April 23, 2010 @04:03PM (#1289319)
68xx and 8051 might be old-school, but you can also synthesize those cores inside an FPGA. That's pretty useful and avoids paying licensing fees for some of the newer stuff.