News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Python's Original Sin by wwortiz on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:00PM (#1288919)
I don't understand python is dead or hurting because jython isn't keeping up with the latest branches?

Edit: Only in a language group like rubyists do you see quick adoption and change and for many applications this isn't always great I'll take stable libraries over ever changing applications any day.

Re:Python's Original Sin by felideon on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:11PM (#1288973)
Re-read the post. It seems like he _used_ to think Python was dead because he thought the Moratorium was implemented for different reasons than the actual rationale.

Now, I'm not sure if he still thinks Python is dead or not, but that's not what his post is about. He was just stating his opinion that Python has a "[...] fundamental design flaw: a syntax which requires human compilation."

Re:Python's Original Sin by wwortiz on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:26PM (#1289030)
I did re-read the post and it just seems like perl 6 has reassured him that python is dying but I have to disagree, maybe jython is dead for what he wants but python is not dead and from the looks of it jython is not dead.
Re:Python's Original Sin by andreyf on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:34PM (#1289067)
Err, I guess this teaches me to not to even mention simplistic emotional responses like "Python is dead". Let me try to be as clear is possible:

Python is not dead. Python is hurting from a bad design decision that doesn't let multiple interpreter implementations share components that they could have. This makes it impossible for minimally maintained branches (like Jython) to keep up with the language, and so hard for better-maintained branches (like IronPython or pypy) that it necessitates a moratorium on the syntax as a whole.

Re:Python's Original Sin by wwortiz on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:46PM (#1289112)
I can understand where you are coming from and even though IronPython and other such things are interesting but from experience python is a much slower moving language, I still interact with systems using python 2.5 and I think the moratorium is a good thing for creating libraries and implementations and overall will make adoption quicker.

I still think python's focus is in a slower world and as a python user I am okay with that.

Re:Python's Original Sin by fuzzyman on Friday April 23, 2010 @08:14PM (#1289908)
"Python is hurting from a bad design decision that doesn't let multiple interpreter implementations share components that they could have."

As many others have said, changing syntax is really one of the most trivial parts for alternative implementations to keep up with when moving to new versions. That "hurt" hasn't been fixed because it doesn't really hurt very much...

Re:Python's Original Sin by andreyf on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:29PM (#1289039)
I don't understand python is [...] hurting because jython isn't keeping up with the latest branches?

Yes, Python has put a moratorium on syntax changes in part because IronPython, Jython, and pypy aren't keeping up with changes. As felideon points out, I regret saying it's dead - it's just that syntax innovation that's dead (and only for a little bit), and that's a shame.