That makes it a bit difficult to interpret the existing literature since you can't always be sure exactly what is being measured.
FWIW, when I was reading it seemed like the majority of the benefit comes from having the baby in the same room as you. It's fine to have them sleep in a bassinet so you can have a bit more room to yourselves. Or just if you don't want to spend all night being kicked by a restless newborn.
On the other hand, if you live your life out of 1 in a million fears, your life is not very awesome.
http://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/3/5/e002299.full.pdf+html?sid...
The risk is low, but it is an avoidable risk...
Towards the end the of paper it says, 'One has to ask whether it is worth taking the risk, however small, of losing a baby, when it can be so easily avoided.' I feel like that's the justification for a lot of safety precautions that each seem like a no-brainer individually, but add up to a sterile and unpleasant (and very low mortality rate) way to raise children. But I do think that's how a lot of people look at it, basically just sleep worse and bond less with your baby to take this risk from something like 1 in 5000 to 1 in 12000. But for us at least, it lowered our quality of life to not have the baby in the bed, so it wasn't really that low cost of a way to decrease the risk, especially given that 1 in 5000 starting point.
The crazy thing about the scare culture around raising children is that you're expected to make all these sacrifices to your quality of life so that you can eke out minuscule gains in the mortality of your infant. But nobody wants to talk about how crazy it is to then strap your kid into a steel box and hurtle around town at 60+ mph.
Remember: all of the statistics and scare stories about co-sleeping are related to alcohol or obesity.
If you are neither drunk nor obese[1], you shouldn't think twice about co-sleeping.
[1] Granted, this does rule out a significant portion of the US population ...