Re:Don't Panic: Facebook is the Private Beta of the Semantic...
by tokenadult on Friday April 23, 2010 @01:07PM
(#1288706)
As a historical fact, corporate mining towns are a thing of the past in the United States, and the great-great-grandchildren of the miners enjoy a prosperity that was unimaginable even to the mine owners back then.
Re:Don't Panic: Facebook is the Private Beta of the Semantic...
by stcredzero on Friday April 23, 2010 @01:39PM
(#1288835)
Thanks for another reiteration of the OP premise. No one disputes history here. The devil's advocate position and the question raised are about the reasons why and how well those factors would work online. If we can figure this out, then this might give us a clue as to how specifically this might play out.
Re:Don't Panic: Facebook is the Private Beta of the Semantic...
by dhimes on Friday April 23, 2010 @03:52PM
(#1289289)
If you are implying that the mining towns caused the current prosperity, it is a non sequitor.
Re:Don't Panic: Facebook is the Private Beta of the Semantic...
by mbleigh on Friday April 23, 2010 @01:06PM
(#1288701)
It works because they can't put the genie back in the bottle. They've now committed to supporting this open protocol and for them to try to take it away would mean breaking thousands of websites. Therefore others are free to build on top of their work without fear of the carpet being pulled out from beneath them.
As to relinquishment, it's a non-issue because Facebook owns nothing to begin with. Users pay attention to whatever suits them best, and when something comes along that does it better than Facebook, well they'll just use that instead.
I would ask why companies lose or relinquish control of such company towns, and would the same factors work online?
To get the ball rolling, I would posit that the same factors won't work. Data can't be relinquished in the same way that land or mineral rights can. For example: once the graph of my college friends is out there, there's no way I can ever reliably take it back.