News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by rms on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @05:19AM (#128746)
I used news.yc to make someone happy the other day. There was a new user that didn't understand why he was getting downmodded so I told him the reason. It seemed like karma really meant a lot to him so I upvoted all of his stories and current comments, giving him an extra 20 karma points. In an economy with infinite karma, I didn't think it was a big deal to arbitrarily give him more. I think he was joking a little when he said it "made his month" but hopefully I made him smile.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=125233

Paul Graham told me via email that up and downarrows aren't for arbitrary karma operations and then a couple days later he took away my ability to vote on any comment or story. I upvoted this story to 4 but it didn't count because I can't vote anymore. I find the whole scenario somewhat bizarre.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by pg on Wednesday March 05, 2008 @12:36PM (#129780)
What you don't mention was (a) this wasn't the first time you'd done this, and (b) that before turning off voting for your account, I tried sending you an email asking you to stop, and you replied basically telling me to fuck off.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by rms on Wednesday March 05, 2008 @05:27PM (#130055)
a) Yes, there were one or two other users that I have karma upbombed. I did it in compensation for comments they made that had gotten to extremely low negative levels. You've previously emailed me several times to stop responding to dead comments and once telling me you killed a comment that suggested using another comment as an impromptu poll. With that email, you said the only reason you didn't ban me from the site was because it was a borderline case.

b) Your email to me was harsh. My response was "Sometimes I think you take yourself too seriously" which was meant not as "fuck you" but "have a sense of humor about up and downarrows."

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by ingenium on Thursday March 06, 2008 @01:58AM (#130392)
Paul, the thing is, you ARE too full of yourself. At the YC interview, when we went around the table and shook hands it went "Hi, I'm Jessica. I'm Trevor. I'm Robert." And then you just smiled, because of course you were Paul. We were just supposed to KNOW who you were....

Taking away rms's voting rights isn't about improving the discourse of this site. It's about your own sense of self superiority.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by pg on Thursday March 06, 2008 @02:09AM (#130397)
You're making up an elaborate theory out of randomness. We interview startups one after another all day long. We don't all say our names every time. Another iteration and maybe it would be Robert who just smiled and said hello. But then of course the evidence you'd select would be something else.

As for Rms: he abuses the voting system, I send him an email asking him to stop, he won't stop. And when I suspend voting for his account after this, it's out of my own "sense of self superiority?" WTF? Any forum administrator would do the same under the circumstances.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by rms on Thursday March 06, 2008 @02:11AM (#130399)
I never said I wouldn't stop. I stopped as soon as you told me too. Sorry for not making that explicitly clear with my email.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by curi on Thursday March 06, 2008 @02:13AM (#130402)
Not any forum administrator. That isn't what I would do.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by yters on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @05:54AM (#128760)
Huh, the community here is changing if people are getting downmodded for long posts.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by rms on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @06:04AM (#128763)
They weren't long posts in the style of nostrademons, they were more stream of consciousness style.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by yters on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @11:55AM (#128938)
That still doesn't speak well of the moderators that they'd rather vote down than explain how he could make his writing better.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by xirium on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @05:27AM (#128751)
The foo is strong in user NSX2 but that grasshopper has a long path to travel.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by rms on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @05:29AM (#128753)
I hope he sticks around. In communities like this some contrarians are a good thing.

(I upvoted you but it didn't count)

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by xirium on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @05:41AM (#128754)
I hope that he sticks around too. He could easily get frustrated with us but he may learn less elsewhere. However, I don't see him as a contrarian; just lacking some old hacker lore.

I'm sorry to learn of your temporary lack of moderation weight. The sentiment is greatly appreciated.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @07:04AM (#128774)
rms -- that's truly ironic. The commenter broke unwritten rules so you helped him out with advice. Then you gave him a bunch of karma, in the process also breaking unwritten rules and getting busted.

And before pg says "it's in writing somewhere" -- the system shouldn't require people poking around the blog to figure out what will work or not.

The whole karma thing gives me a headache. It's supposed to be for good articles, except in the case where you use it to agree or disagree, unless you disagree and you don't have enough karma, unless you use it too much, in which case...

Ugh. It's like by insisting that it's a simple up and down arrow we've made the whole thing much more complicated than it needs to be. But hey! It looks simple on the page! I guess that's something.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by ghiotion on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @10:08AM (#128878)
> the system shouldn't require people poking around the blog to figure out what will work or not.

I don't agree with that. The Internet has allowed way to many folk's inner Id (i.e. Id, Ego, Superego) to run a muck. They see some snippet of something or other that offends their delicate sensibilities and they go apeshit in the comments. HN is based on what should be a simple idea: don't say anything in the comments that you wouldn't be willing to say to someone in person. There are variants on this theme: be thoughtful, don't be abrasive, [perhaps] keep your politics to yourself, etc. If someone gets riposted for their comments they ought to ask themselves, what am I doing wrong? Not, what's wrong with the community. If they're incapable of doing that, they probably don't belong here in the first place.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by matth on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @11:01AM (#128906)
> If someone gets riposted for their comments they ought to ask themselves, what am I doing wrong? Not, what's wrong with the community.

Have you ever seen THX 1138? It's a good movie.

In all seriousness... lets try to admit there are problems here. I lurk more than I post for simple fear of bothering someone's sensibilities. In fact, when I do post, I tend to generalize so I don't lose half my karma.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by ghiotion on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @12:43PM (#128976)
> Have you ever seen THX 1138?

I have. It's shocking to see Robert Duvall so young. I saw [Edit: not One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, but To Kill a Mockingbird -- duh] recently and I couldn't believe he was Bo Bradley.

Anyway... I've found the people on here to be a bright group. Even when I post comments that get downvoted, I understand the reasons. Frankly, losing my karma doesn't bother me too much. As long as you can make your case intelligently, you'll be fine. For example, I made a comment defending spanking (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=127794) which I knew wouldn't be a popular stance. However, my approach was measured and, even though the majority disagreed, the comment itself wasn't viciously downvoted. The internet tends to distort one's sense of humanity. The bulk of the people out there are reasonable, the existence of 4chan notwithstanding.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by matth on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @07:12PM (#129315)
I agree with you!

However, I'll add the caveat that things tend to get a little crazy around YC application deadlines. My feeling is that some people seem to feel the need to 'fall in line' around that time.

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by aston on Wednesday March 05, 2008 @05:15AM (#129602)
Boo Radley
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by mrtron on Saturday March 29, 2008 @05:11PM (#149663)
I just stared at the 'Bo Radley' for a minute and thought...isn't it 'Boo'? Or maybe just pronounced that way?

You saved me looking it up :)

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @10:19AM (#128883)
You're making an argument around the virtues of HN. I agree with them. My point is about how software should operate not a bout how the community should operate. Good software should be simple to use and understand. You say you do not agree with what I said, yet it does not look like you have addressed my point. Perhaps I made my point poorly. If so, apologies.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by ghiotion on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @10:27AM (#128887)
I think I understand where you're coming from and I agree with you that good software should be simple and easy to use/understand. And, I think HN is. At it's heart, it's simple software. My point was that the software doesn't stand in isolation; the community shapes and molds the behavior of the software. In a very real sense, the community is the software. HN lives (and dies) by how interesting the people who use it are.
Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @10:52AM (#128901)
While I'm onboard with the community + software = experience, let's look at the problems.

Let's say I posted a comment, "I love monkeys" and got down-voted to like -10 or something. Aside from relevance questions, perhaps HN is an anti-monkey society. How, from just the score, am I supposed to know that? In other words, by limiting my choice to simple up or down arrows, it makes the other guy scratch his head trying to figure out exactly how his comment was misconfigured for the group. So then he has to plead for somebody to explain that to him. Hopefully, he will get an explanation from somebody who represents the majority of downvoters, but that doesn't have to be the case. He's just as likely to receive advice from somebody, as in this case, who didn't know other huge parts of the community rules.

I love the social networking aspect of the site. But I'm not a fan of the current software as a communication tool between users or as something that would increase (instead of decrease) that experience. BTW, that's why so many "here's my picture of Dilbert" articles are posted -- there's less risk in offending anyone, and heck, you can't figure out what you did when you get downvoted anyway, so might as well go with easy, fast, and funny content over content that might have more substance (and be riskier from the point of view of the submitter)

Re:Ask YC: What software makes you happy? by rms on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @07:20AM (#128783)
Upvoted!