News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by mtw on Thursday November 03, 2016 @05:29PM (#12868137)
This would have been the perfect election to have a third alternative. But unfortunately, the american political system is not made for this. Time for change?
Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by wrsh07 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @05:44PM (#12868279)
There's a "law" that describes this: Duverger's Law [1]

Pedantry follows:

First past the post is [more or less] the election system we have - you select one candidate. Candidate with plurality [that's a generalization of a majority, ie the person with the most votes even if they don't have > 50%] wins.

There are lots of alternatives, and even a ballot initiative in Maine [2] to switch to a different type of voting system known as Ranked Choice Voting.

New types of voting systems are exciting, but complexity lends itself to a poor user interface. So more sophisticated forms of voting actually depress poll #s [I'll just cite Harry talking about this ballot initiative in this podcast [3]].

If you're looking to ever have a real alternative to the big two, the path to that is convincing your local government to switch voting systems.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law [2]: https://ballotpedia.org/Maine_Ranked_Choice_Voting_Initiativ... [3]: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/elections-podcast-countd...

[Edit: put scare quotes around law]

Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by abecedarius on Thursday November 03, 2016 @06:27PM (#12868597)
The issue of complexity is why I'd push for approval voting (i.e. you can upvote multiple candidates). http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ shows some of the weirdness that comes up with ranked choice voting (what I'd always heard of before as instant runoff voting). It looks even more surprising than what we have!

I've been wondering recently if California would go for a ballot initiative to change their primaries to approval voting or score voting or some other reasonable improvement. Since recently the state has open primaries, meaning you might end up with a general election between two Democrats, or two Republicans, and other weirdness. I can imagine less resistance to a change here, than for the mechanism of the general election.

Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by wrsh07 on Friday November 04, 2016 @06:22PM (#12876669)
Majority judgment or judgment voting is interesting / more general than merely up vote + down vote.

I think the most important thing is for voters to want to experiment. And to be engaged.

Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by perilunar on Thursday November 03, 2016 @09:08PM (#12869602)
In Australia we use Preferential or Optional Preferential voting (aka Instant Runoff) for pretty much all elections (federal, state and local), and it works reasonably well. First-past-the-post voting seems like a completely backward way to vote, and perfectly designed to make voting for a third party candidate a difficult choice.
Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by acedinlowball on Friday November 04, 2016 @01:52PM (#12874462)
Also known as First Past the Post.
Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by wrsh07 on Friday November 04, 2016 @06:20PM (#12876652)
Yes, I even named it in my post
Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by knz on Thursday November 03, 2016 @05:40PM (#12868241)
I don't disagree but I do wonder what that would even look like.

Do we need to change the system? The players/politicians? Groups exerting influence onto the system (the media, big business, big unions)? Push more decisions to the State level?

Good luck untangling that mess... we can't even agree to end crap like gerrymandering and voter suppression.

Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by jmcphers on Thursday November 03, 2016 @06:10PM (#12868468)
Currently we have two candidates, who are each more or less reviled by at least 50% of the population.

Would it really be better to have three candidates, each of which was more or less reviled by 66% of the population?

The truth is that Americans don't agree on many major issues, and that the major parties are a personification of this unhappy fact. Adding more parties doesn't help that. In fact, splitting the vote among more parties makes it likely that the elected official will represent the views of fewer of the total electorate!

Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by krapp on Thursday November 03, 2016 @06:21PM (#12868546)
> In fact, splitting the vote among more parties makes it likely that the elected official will represent the views of fewer of the total electorate!

The obvious answer to this is to dismantle the Federal system, devolve as much power as possible to the states, and perhaps abolish the office of President altogether.

It would probably be a terrible idea on the one hand, but on the other hand, no more Presidential elections.

Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by CalChris on Thursday November 03, 2016 @07:07PM (#12868901)
I've often wished to be on the other side of the fence with a proportionally representing parliament. You can take a look at other parliamentary systems in the world and it's not markedly better or worse. There are other structural changes I'd make first (direct Presidential election, ...).
Re:Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close? by merpnderp on Thursday November 03, 2016 @05:33PM (#12868175)
But which party is going to spearhead allowing for more party choice?